Judges Are Not Liable for Every Wrong Order: Supreme Court Reaffirms Good Faith Protection in Judicial Decisions

The Supreme Court held that judicial error alone is not misconduct; parties must use appeals or certiorari unless fraud, bad faith, or corruption is proven. A judgeโ€™s mistaken ruling is not automatically judicial misconduct. Parties who believe a court order is wrong must ordinarily challenge it through appeal, certiorari, or other judicial remediesโ€”not by turning […]

When a Court Delays a Summary Case, Justice Can Become an Administrative Offense

A judge may be fined for delaying a summary procedure case, but alleged legal errors must be addressed through appeal, not administrative discipline. Parties in supposedly fast-track cases are entitled not only to a correct judgment, but to a timely one. The doctrine from Monfort Hermanos is straightforward but powerful: a judge may not excuse […]

Administrative Complaints Are Not Appeals: When Court Errors Must Be Challenged Through Remedies, Not Discipline Cases

A judge is not disciplined for alleged wrong rulings absent proof of bad faith or misconduct; litigants must use appeal, reconsideration, or certiorari. Parties who believe a judge made a wrong ruling cannot automatically turn that grievance into an administrative case. The controlling lesson is practical and important: judicial discipline is not a substitute for […]

When a Judge Makes a Legal Error, Discipline Still Requires More Than a Wrong Ruling

A wrong ruling does not automatically discipline a judge, but unexplained delay in resolving motions may still lead to sanctions and judicial accountability. A wrong court order does not automatically make a judge administratively liable, but unexplained delay in resolving a pending motion can still result in discipline. For litigants, the distinction is important: judicial […]

A Wrong Court Ruling Is Not Enough to Discipline a Judge

A wrong ruling alone is not judicial misconduct. The remedy is appeal or review unless bad faith, corruption, dishonesty, or deliberate legal defiance is shown. Parties who lose in court cannot turn an unfavorable judgment into an administrative case against the judge unless they can show more than legal error. The ruling in Louis Vuitton […]