Good-Faith Tax Protest Defeats Criminal Tax Evasion Charge, But Deficiency Tax Still Must Be Paid

A taxpayer was acquitted of willful failure to pay tax due to reasonable doubt, but the corporation remained liable for deficiency income tax. Taxpayers accused of willfully refusing to pay a BIR assessment may avoid criminal conviction when the evidence shows a good-faith dispute, but acquittal does not automatically erase the underlying tax liability. Businesses […]

Improper LOA Service Can Void a BIR Assessment Despite Taxpayer Cooperation

Improper BIR Letter of Authority service on an unauthorized driver voided the audit and tax assessment despite the taxpayer’s later cooperation. Taxpayers facing deficiency tax assessments should closely examine how the BIR served the Letter of Authority because an audit that begins with improper LOA service may be void from the start, even if the […]

Late Formal Offer of Evidence Can Defeat a Tax Assessment Appeal

A taxpayer lost reconsideration after late extension motions led to exclusion of its Formal Offer of Evidence in a BIR assessment appeal. Taxpayers contesting a BIR assessment before the Court of Tax Appeals must treat procedural deadlines as litigation-critical. A late motion to extend the filing of a Formal Offer of Evidence may result in […]

Tax Regulation Ultra Vires Rule: When BIR Rules Go Too Far

BIR tax rules are void when they expand the Tax Code, restrict deductions, or impose accounting methods without legal basis. Taxpayers may challenge a revenue regulation when the BIR or Department of Finance uses rulemaking to impose burdens that Congress itself did not authorize. The Tax Regulation Ultra Vires Rule confirms that administrative agencies may […]

MCIT Direct Cost Rule: Insurance Taxes Are Not Service Costs

For MCIT, insurance premium taxes and DST are not direct service costs; policy coverage increases can trigger additional DST liability. The MCIT Direct Cost Rule matters because companies cannot reduce minimum corporate income tax by treating every business-related tax or expense as a cost of service. For Philippine corporations, especially insurance companies and other service […]

Tax Abatement Termination Letter: When BIR Relief Becomes Final

BIR tax abatement is final only with a termination letter; payment forms alone do not close deficiency tax assessments. Taxpayers who apply for BIR tax abatement cannot treat an assessment as closed simply because they paid the basic tax or submitted abatement forms. Under the tax abatement termination letter doctrine, the assessment remains enforceable until […]

PAGCOR Licensee Tax Exemption: Casino Gaming Income Needs Only 5%

PAGCOR licensees owe only 5% franchise tax on casino gaming income; BIR cannot impose corporate income tax by circular. PAGCOR contractees and licensees operating authorized casinos are not automatically liable for corporate income tax on gaming income merely because the BIR issued a circular saying so. Under the PAGCOR Licensee Tax Exemption doctrine, income derived […]

Strict DST Rule: When Interbank Call Loans Are Not Taxable

Interbank call loans are not subject to DST unless clearly taxed by law; later tax code amendments cannot retroactively burden taxpayers. Banks cannot be made to pay documentary stamp tax on interbank call loans unless the tax law clearly, expressly, and unambiguously includes those transactions among taxable instruments. The Strict DST Rule matters because it […]

Tax Amnesty for Documentary Stamp Tax: What Banks Can Claim

Documentary stamp tax may be covered by tax amnesty when it is a direct liability, and BIR circulars cannot add exclusions beyond the law. Taxpayers facing old documentary stamp tax assessments may still invoke tax amnesty when the liability is their own direct tax obligation, not money they merely withheld or collected in trust for […]