Unauthorized BIR Examiners Can Void a Deficiency Tax Assessment

A PHP53.77M BIR assessment was cancelled after substitute audit personnel acted without a new LOA, reinforcing due process defenses in tax audits. Taxpayers facing a BIR deficiency tax assessment should closely examine whether every revenue officer and group supervisor who actually participated in the audit was named in a valid Letter of Authority. In this […]

Due Process Violation Voids Tax Assessment and Levy on Apex 5678 Rockwell Inc.

Apex 5678 Rockwell Inc.’s 2017 tax assessments and related WDL were void due to improper service, affirming the necessity of due process in tax notices. Taxpayers must be formally notified of any tax assessments to protect their due process rights. In this case, Apex 5678 Rockwell Inc. successfully challenged the 2017 deficiency income tax, value-added […]

BIR Assessments Can Be Voided When Revenue Officers Lack Proper Authority or the Notice Has No Due Date

Taxpayers can defeat BIR assessments when unauthorized revenue officers conduct the audit or the final assessment notice lacks a definite due date for payment. Taxpayers facing BIR deficiency assessments should closely review whether every revenue officer who participated in the audit was named in a valid Letter of Authority and whether the final assessment notice […]

BIR Collection Defeated When Taxpayer Proves Defective Service of Final Assessment

Taxpayer defeats P6.30M VAT assessment after BIR failed to prove proper service of the final assessment, voiding the collection warrant. A taxpayer facing BIR collection by warrant may still challenge the collection if the BIR cannot prove that the final assessment was properly served and received. In this assessment dispute, the Court cancelled a P6.30 […]

Tax Exempt Procurement Is Not a Shield Against Withholding Tax

Tax-exempt government procurement does not erase withholding duties. COMELEC remained liable for basic EWT, but not deficiency interest. A government agency may be exempt from paying taxes on a procurement, but it can still be liable as a withholding agent when it pays taxable suppliers. That is the practical rule from the Supreme Court’s ruling […]

Tax Rules Apply Prospectively: Why Airlines Could Not Use a Later BIR Regulation to Reduce Past Percentage Taxes

A later BIR regulation could not reduce Gulf Airโ€™s past percentage tax liability; tax rules apply prospectively and refund claims are strictly proven. Taxpayers cannot use a later, more favorable BIR regulation to undo tax liabilities from an earlier period unless the regulation itself clearly applies retroactively. For businesses seeking tax refunds or contesting assessments, […]

Tax Evasion Cases Can Proceed Even Without a Formal BIR Assessment

Fraudulent tax return cases may proceed without a formal BIR assessment; a DOJ referral is not an appealable tax assessment before the CTA. Taxpayers suspected of filing fraudulent tax returns cannot stop a tax evasion case simply by arguing that the Bureau of Internal Revenue has not yet issued a formal assessment. When the alleged […]

No-Assessment Tax Evasion Rule: When BIR Can Prosecute First

Fraudulent tax returns may trigger criminal tax prosecution even without a BIR assessment; prosecution papers are not tax assessments. The No-Assessment Tax Evasion Rule means that a taxpayer suspected of filing a fraudulent return cannot always wait for a final BIR assessment before facing criminal prosecution. For business owners, corporate officers, and tax managers, the […]

Declaratory Relief and Tax Assessment Limits: Supreme Court Upholds CA No. 55

Supreme Court reaffirms that declaratory relief cannot contest tax assessments; CA No. 55 bars direct court action, requiring administrative remedies first. Taxpayers seeking to challenge BIR or BOC assessments via declaratory relief cannot bypass established administrative remedies; the Supreme Court reaffirms that CA No. 55 bars such petitions. Background: The Dispute CJH Development Corporation (CJH) […]