When a BIR Waiver Fails, the Tax Assessment Can Die With It

A defective BIR waiver did not extend the three-year tax assessment period, making the deficiency assessment against FMF Development time-barred. Taxpayers can defeat a BIR assessment on prescription when the supposed waiver extending the assessment period is defective. A waiver of the statute of limitations is not a blank check for the government: it must […]

When Business Advances Are Not Bad Debts: Why Joint Venture Losses May Still Be Taxable

The Supreme Court held that Philex Mining’s project advances were joint venture contributions, not deductible bad debts, sustaining the BIR tax assessment. A company cannot turn failed investment advances into deductible bad debts merely by calling them receivables after the venture collapses. If the agreement shows that the parties pooled money, property, expertise, and profits […]

RMO No. 26-2001: 15-Day Prosecution Division Review for BIR Tax Fraud and Tax Evasion Cases Before PAN Issuance

RMO No. 26-2001 requires 15-day Prosecution Division review of tax fraud or evasion cases before PAN issuance, focusing on evidentiary sufficiency. Taxpayers facing a BIR tax fraud or tax evasion investigation must now expect a specific pre-assessment criminal review step: investigation reports recommending criminal prosecution must first be reviewed by the Prosecution Division within 15 […]

Unsigned BIR Waivers Cannot Extend the Deadline to Assess Taxes

A taxpayer-only waiver cannot extend the BIR’s assessment deadline. The Supreme Court voided late tax assessments issued without a valid written agreement. A tax assessment issued after the legal deadline is void when the taxpayer’s supposed waiver of prescription was not validly accepted in writing by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. A taxpayer’s signature alone […]

When Taxpayers Refuse to Show Their Books, the BIR May Reconstruct the Tax Due

When taxpayers withhold or fail to produce books, the BIR may reconstruct liability using the best evidence obtainable, and assessments are presumed correct. Taxpayers who refuse or fail to produce their books of accounts cannot expect a court to strike down a BIR assessment merely because the BIR relied on indirect evidence. Where tax records […]