Tax Refund Claims Can Survive Prescription Challenges When the BIR Merely Rehashes Old Arguments

Taxpayers defending refund claims should preserve prescription arguments early; the court denied the Commissioner’s MR and sustained a CGT refund. Taxpayers who have already secured a tax refund victory should be ready to defend that ruling against post-decision challenges, but a reconsideration motion that simply repeats previously rejected prescription arguments will not, by itself, justify […]

BIR Cannot Revive Prescribed Tax Assessments Without Clear Proof of Fraud

Old BIR VAT and withholding tax assessments were cancelled after the tax court found no clear proof of fraud to extend the three-year assessment period. Tax assessments issued beyond the ordinary three-year period remain vulnerable to cancellation when the Commissioner relies only on allegations of false or fraudulent returns, without clear proof of intentional falsity. […]

Void Tax Assessment Rule: When BIR Due Process Failures Defeat Tax Claims

BIR tax assessments are void when due process, notice, legal basis, or prescription rules are violated, defeating collection claims. Taxpayers may defeat a deficiency tax assessment when the Bureau of Internal Revenue fails to prove that it properly served the required notices, states the wrong legal basis, or issues an assessment after the prescriptive period. […]