When Retained Earnings Become Taxable: The Business-Need Rule for Philippine Corporations

Cyanamid clarifies that retained earnings must be proven necessary for business needs, or corporations may face improperly accumulated earnings tax after a BIR assessment. Corporations that keep profits instead of declaring dividends cannot rely on broad claims of โ€œworking capitalโ€ to avoid the improperly accumulated earnings tax. The controlling lesson of Cyanamid Philippines is practical […]

When Retained Earnings Become Taxable: The Cyanamid Rule on Improperly Accumulated Profits

Cyanamid confirms that retained earnings may be taxed when a corporation cannot prove they are needed for immediate, reasonable business purposes. Corporations that keep profits inside the company instead of declaring dividends may be taxed if they cannot prove that the retained earnings are needed for the immediate and reasonable needs of the business. The […]

When Retained Earnings Become Taxable: The Working Capital Test for Corporate Surplus

Companies retaining large profits must prove genuine working capital needs or risk accumulated earnings tax, even if wholly owned by a foreign parent. Corporations cannot defeat the accumulated earnings tax merely by saying that retained profits are needed as working capital. When a company keeps profits instead of distributing dividends, it must be ready to […]

RMO No. 43-99: Assistant Commissioner for Collection Service Authorized to Sign ITS-Generated Assessment Notices for Large Taxpayers

RMO No. 43-99 authorizes the Assistant Commissioner, Collection Service to sign ITS-generated Assessment Notices for large taxpayers. Large taxpayers receiving ITS-generated Assessment Notices should treat notices signed by the Assistant Commissioner, Collection Service as validly signed under delegated authority. RMO No. 43-99 matters because it identifies the BIR official authorized to sign assessment notices generated […]

Tax Courts Cannot Rewrite Tax Policy: Why Jewelry Taxes Survived a Constitutional Challenge

The Supreme Court held that courts cannot invalidate jewelry taxes merely because they seem harsh or unwise; tax policy belongs to Congress. Businesses cannot defeat a tax law merely by showing that it is harsh, commercially inconvenient, or less competitive than tax policies in other countries. The controlling doctrine from this ruling is simple but […]

Estate Tax Collection Doctrine: Probate Cannot Stop the BIR

Estate tax assessments become final if not protested; probate proceedings cannot block BIR levy once a demandable deficiency tax exists under Philippine law. Estate tax liabilities cannot be delayed simply because an estate is still under probate. The Estate Tax Collection Doctrine means that once a deficiency tax assessment becomes final and demandable, the Bureau […]

When a Tax Refund Claim Meets a Deficiency Assessment, the CTA Must Decide Both Together

A taxpayerโ€™s refund claim must be resolved together with any related deficiency assessment to determine the true tax due or refundable amount. A taxpayer claiming an income tax refund cannot rely on an overpayment return alone when the government has raised a deficiency assessment for the same taxable year. The refund case must determine the […]

When Foreign Airlines Sell Tickets in the Philippines, Philippine Income Tax May Follow

Foreign airlines selling tickets in the Philippines may owe Philippine income tax even without local flights, but fraud surcharges require clear proof. Foreign corporations cannot avoid Philippine income tax merely because their aircraft do not physically fly into or out of the country. When a foreign airline continuously sells tickets here through a local agent, […]

When a Franchise Tax Exemption Still Shields a Company From Income Tax

The Supreme Court held that a franchise tax exemption may shield franchise income from corporate income tax, but not income earned outside the franchise. A company holding a legislative franchise with an โ€œin lieu of all taxesโ€ clause may remain protected from corporate income tax on income earned within the franchise, even if the tax […]