When Corporate Control Is Disputed, Courts Cannot Use Injunctions to Decide the Boardroom War Early

A disputed corporate election cannot justify injunction without a clear legal right, especially where estate shares, voting authority, and quorum remain unresolved. A faction claiming control of a corporation cannot obtain a preliminary injunction merely by presenting a disputed election as presumptively valid. When the right to manage the company depends on contested voting rights, […]

When a Corporate Election Dispute Must Be Filed Within 15 Days

Corporate election challenges involving proxies, quorum, or board authority must be filed within 15 days, or courts may bar evidence on election validity. Corporate members who want to challenge the authority of elected directors cannot wait until a later disciplinary or governance dispute arises before attacking the election. If the complaint questions the validation of […]

Corporate Election Deadlines Cannot Be Avoided by Calling the Case a Meeting Nullity Action

A shareholder challenge to void a stockholders’ meeting was treated as a time-barred election contest because it would nullify the board election. A shareholder who wants to undo a corporate election cannot avoid the 15-day deadline for election contests simply by asking the court to void the entire annual stockholders’ meeting. If the practical effect […]

Corporate Settlements Can End Litigation Even After Submission for Decision

The Supreme Court allowed withdrawal after settlement and denied intervention by a former counsel with only a contingent corporate interest. Corporate litigants who have resolved their boardroom dispute may ask the court to end the case even after it has been submitted for resolution, and a former lawyer or corporate officer cannot keep the lawsuit […]

When Corporate Factions Sue Too Many Times: The Supreme Court’s Warning Against Forum Shopping

The Supreme Court clarified forum shopping limits, management committee relief, and voting rules in non-stock corporate leadership disputes. Corporate and association disputes cannot be fought through repeated, overlapping cases in different tribunals just to secure a more favorable ruling. When rival factions recycle the same allegations, parties, and reliefs across multiple proceedings, courts may treat […]

Stock Transfers Must Be Registered Before Buyers Can Vote or Control the Corporation

Share buyers cannot vote against the corporation until transfers are recorded in corporate books; injunction may preserve control during disputes. A buyer of corporate shares does not automatically become a voting stockholder against the corporation simply because a deed of sale has been signed. Until the transfer is recorded in the corporate books, the corporation […]

No Board Seat by Custom: Association Directors Must Be Elected, Not Installed by Practice

Board seats in associations and non-stock corporations must be legally elected; custom or tolerance cannot create a permanent director’s seat. A corporation or homeowners’ association cannot create a permanent board seat through custom, tolerance, or an unapproved amendment to its by-laws. Even long-standing practice does not ripen into a vested right when the seat violates […]

When a Corporation Is Also a Joint Venture: Voting Agreements, Foreign Investors, and Board Control in the Philippines

Shareholder voting agreements in Philippine joint ventures may be enforced, but foreign investors may protect proportional board rights without taking control. Business partners who form a Philippine corporation may still be bound by their deeper joint venture agreement, especially when that agreement allocates board seats, protects minority investors, and defines how voting rights must be […]