When a Union Election Cannot Be Delayed by Signature Challenges

The Supreme Court ordered a certification election despite signature disputes, emphasizing employee choice over delays in union representation cases. Workers seeking to choose a bargaining representative should not lose their chance at a certification election merely because the employer or a rival union questions the petitioning union’s signature count, especially where the workplace has had […]

Expired CBAs Can Make Certification Challenges Moot: Why Timing Matters in Labor Disputes

A CBA certification challenge was dismissed as moot because the agreement had expired, leaving no practical relief for the Court to grant. Labor challenges can become legally useless when the agreement being attacked has already expired and no practical relief can still be granted. For employers, unions, and workers, Bongat teaches a hard procedural lesson: […]

Employers Must Stay Out of Union Certification Elections, Even During Workplace Unrest

Employers cannot block or influence certification elections; worker choice of bargaining agent remains protected even amid unrest or security concerns. Employers facing a union certification election cannot defeat or delay the process by claiming to protect employees from the union, by questioning the workers’ choice of bargaining agent, or by invoking general peace-and-order concerns. The […]

Workers Can Still Choose Their Union Even When Internal Union Politics Are Messy

The Court upheld a certification election despite union faction disputes, emphasizing worker choice and rejecting protests by an unregistered breakaway group. Employees do not lose their right to choose a bargaining representative simply because rival union leaders are fighting among themselves. When workers are given a peaceful and orderly certification election, and the winning union […]

A Renewed CBA Cannot Block a Certification Election When It Was Signed Too Early

A prematurely renewed CBA cannot block a certification election when it frustrates employees’ right to choose their bargaining representative. Rank-and-file employees cannot be locked into a bargaining representative by a collective bargaining agreement rushed into existence before the law’s certification-election window. When management and an incumbent union renew a CBA ahead of the prescribed freedom […]

Employers Cannot Block a Union Vote by Turning Signature Disputes Into Technical Objections

Employers cannot block a certification election through technical signature objections when the labor authority finds voting is the best test of employee choice. Employers facing a certification election petition cannot defeat the workers’ choice of bargaining representative by relying on technical objections to the union’s initial signature count when the labor authority has sufficient basis […]

Workers Can Break Away From a Union and Demand a Certification Election

Workers who leave an incumbent union may form a new union and seek a certification election despite an existing CBA or prior bargaining agent. Employees who disaffiliate from an existing union are not trapped by a prior bargaining relationship: once their right to choose a new representative is put in issue, the proper remedy is […]

When Separate Plant Workers Can Join One Certification Election

Separate plant workers may join one certification election when affected unions agree, labor authorities raise no objection, and timing concerns under an existing CBA lapse. Workers in a separate plant may be included in a certification election when the affected unions, the labor authorities, and the employer’s own position leave no substantial objection to their […]