When Judicial Error Is Not Misconduct: Why Good-Faith Court Action Matters in Administrative Complaints

A judge’s good-faith error in executing a court order is not automatically misconduct. Administrative charges require proof, causation, and active prosecution. Administrative liability does not automatically follow from every mistaken court action. For taxpayers, business owners, and litigants who suffer from a wrong order, delayed release, or procedural mistake, Mangaron v. Judge Bagano teaches a […]

One-Day Appeal Delay Should Not Defeat Substantial Justice

A one-day appeal delay may be excused when there is substantial compliance, good faith, no prejudice, and dismissal would sacrifice justice to technicality. A one-day delay in filing an appeal record should not automatically destroy a party’s right to appellate review when the appellant substantially complied with the rules, acted in good faith, caused no […]

A Timely Appeal Should Not Be Lost to a Curable Record Defect

A timely appeal should not be dismissed for a curable record defect when the facts show timely filing and no genuine dispute exists. A party who filed an appeal on time should not automatically lose that appeal merely because the record on appeal omitted a date that could later be verified from the record and […]

When a Motion for Reconsideration Saves an Appeal Deadline

A timely motion for reconsideration suspends the appeal period, protecting litigants from losing appellate rights while a court motion remains unresolved. A party who timely asks the trial court to reconsider an adverse ruling does not lose the right to appeal while that request remains unresolved. For taxpayers, corporations, property owners, and litigants facing strict […]

The Foreclosure Value Rule: Why a Small Collection Case Can Still Belong in a Higher Court

A small debt collection case may still belong in a higher court when it also seeks foreclosure of valuable mortgaged personal property. A creditor’s case is not automatically a small money claim simply because the principal amount demanded is low. When the complaint also seeks foreclosure of a chattel mortgage, jurisdiction may turn on the […]

Not Every Postponement Is Legal Malpractice: Why Proof Still Matters in Complaints Against Lawyers

Lawyer discipline for case delay requires proof. The Court dismissed a malpractice complaint where postponements were explained, corroborated, and court-approved. Clients and opposing parties may complain when a lawyer appears to delay a case, but delay alone is not professional misconduct. The controlling lesson is the evidence-based discipline doctrine: a lawyer cannot be sanctioned for […]

When New Procedural Rules Overtake a Pending Criminal Challenge

A procedural attack on preliminary investigation may fail when later legal changes validate the challenged prosecutor authority and procedure. People challenging a prosecutor’s authority in a pending criminal matter can lose the case when the very procedure they attack is later adopted as part of controlling law. In Litton v. Castillo, the Supreme Court treated […]

When a Court Fight Becomes Moot, Even a Pending Injunction Case Can End Immediately

A petition may be dismissed once the challenged injunction is lifted and the underlying case is dismissed, because courts do not issue advisory opinions. Courts will not spend time deciding a case after the live dispute has disappeared. For taxpayers, businesses, and litigants seeking injunctions, the practical lesson is direct: once the underlying case or […]

When Clients Settle Behind Their Lawyer’s Back, Attorney’s Fees May Still Survive

A client may settle a case without counsel, but a recorded contingent fee can survive if the compromise unfairly defeats the lawyer’s lien. A client may compromise or dismiss a case without the lawyer’s consent, but that freedom does not automatically erase the lawyer’s right to be paid when the settlement unfairly defeats a valid […]