Judges Cannot Be Disciplined Just Because a Party Disagrees With Their Ruling

The Supreme Court dismissed complaints against a judge, holding that parties must use judicial remedies first before filing disciplinary cases over adverse rulings. A party who loses before a judge cannot immediately convert that loss into an administrative case against the judge. The Supreme Court reaffirmed a practical but often overlooked rule: when a judicial […]

When a Pending Certiorari Petition Does Not Stop a Case: Why Courts Must Still Act Unless Restrained

Certiorari does not automatically stop proceedings. Courts must act unless restrained, and undue delay in resolving motions may be sanctioned. A pending petition for certiorari does not automatically freeze proceedings in the lower court or appellate court. Unless the higher court issues a temporary restraining order or writ of preliminary injunction, judges and justices must […]

When a Judge Makes a Legal Error, Discipline Still Requires More Than a Wrong Ruling

A wrong ruling does not automatically discipline a judge, but unexplained delay in resolving motions may still lead to sanctions and judicial accountability. A wrong court order does not automatically make a judge administratively liable, but unexplained delay in resolving a pending motion can still result in discipline. For litigants, the distinction is important: judicial […]

No Second Bite at Certiorari: Final Supreme Court Rulings Bind Parties Who Already Had Their Day in Court

The Court dismissed a repeat certiorari petition because the same administrative decision had already been reviewed, reinforcing finality in tax and labor disputes. A party cannot keep relitigating the same administrative decision by changing procedural posture or filing a new petition after the Supreme Court has already passed upon the issue. For taxpayers, employers, unions, […]

Timber License Privilege Rule: Why Permits Are Not Property Rights

Government timber licenses are privileges, not property rights, and may be revoked for public welfare when administrative remedies are bypassed. The Timber License Privilege Rule makes one lesson clear for concessionaires and regulated businesses: a government license to exploit natural resources is not a vested property right, and it may be withdrawn when public welfare, […]

Certiorari Is Not a Shortcut When an Ordinary Appeal Is Available

Certiorari cannot replace an available appeal. Enriquez v. Rivera warns litigants that using the wrong remedy may doom even a serious procedural challenge. Certiorari is an extraordinary remedy, not a second route for a losing litigant who still has an ordinary appeal. For taxpayers, property owners, employers, and businesses challenging adverse court or agency orders, […]

No Shortcut Around Specialized Tax and Compensation Tribunals

Specialized tribunal rulings cannot be attacked through ordinary injunction suits when the law provides a specific appeal route. Forum choice is decisive. Courts of general jurisdiction cannot be used as a backdoor appeal from specialized tribunals. When the law assigns a dispute to a special body and provides a specific mode of review, a losing […]

When the Government Misses Its Appeal Deadline, Certiorari Cannot Rescue the Case

Certiorari cannot replace a missed appeal from an order granting new trial, a rule vital in criminal, tax, and regulatory enforcement litigation. Procedural finality can decide a criminal case before the court ever reaches the merits. When an order granting a new trial is appealable, the losing party must appeal on time; it cannot wait, […]

When the Dispute Expires, the Appeal May Die With It

A Supreme Court ruling explains why courts may dismiss appeals once the dispute has expired, warning taxpayers and litigants to preserve timely remedies. Courts do not decide cases merely to settle abstract legal questions. When the office, benefit, ruling, or controversy at the center of a case has already expired, an appeal may be dismissed […]

Contempt Orders Must Be Challenged Before the Court That Issued Them

A contempt order must be challenged first before the court that issued it, even when parties later agree the contempt arose from mistake. A party found in contempt cannot cure the problem by asking the reviewing court to undo the contempt finding when the case has already been elevated on appeal. The proper remedy begins […]