Legal Insanity Can Acquit an Accused but Not Erase Civil Liability

Legal insanity may acquit an accused from parricide, but civil damages and court-ordered psychiatric confinement may still follow. An accused who proves legal insanity may be acquitted even after trial and appeal, but the acquittal does not automatically free the accused from paying damages to the victim’s heirs. The ruling matters because it separates criminal […]

When a Bad Deal Is Also Illegal: Why Courts May Refuse to Return Money Paid for Public Office

Supreme Court acquits one estafa accused, affirms another’s conviction, but bars recovery of money paid for an illegal party-list seat deal. Money paid for an unlawful promise to secure public office may not be recoverable in court, even when the transaction also involved deceit. In Morales, the Supreme Court acquitted one accused for lack of […]

Tax Collection Orders Can Be Reversed When the BIR Acts Too Late or Relies Only on Assessments

The tax court reversed a P51.2M civil tax payment order after finding prescription and lack of competent proof of unpaid taxes in a criminal tax case. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges should not assume that an acquittal automatically ends the financial exposure, but this ruling shows that the government must still prove and timely pursue […]

A Wrong Caption Should Not Erase a Corporation’s Right to Recover Civil Liability

A corporation’s civil claim survives a wrong case caption when records show its interest and its officer’s authority in a B.P. 22-related dispute. A defective or changed case caption does not automatically defeat a corporation’s right to recover civil liability when the record clearly shows that the corporation was the real party affected and that […]

Corporate Officers Are Not Personal Guarantors of Company Debts Without Clear Proof of Bad Faith

Corporate officers are not personally liable for company debts absent clear proof of bad faith, gross negligence, or patently unlawful corporate acts. A corporate officer who signs a company transaction does not automatically become personally liable when the corporation later fails to perform. The doctrine is practical and protective: creditors may pursue the corporation that […]

When Director Pay Is Not Automatically Illegal: The Corporate Compensation Rule Every School and Family Corporation Should Know

Directors may be paid for real officer services, not merely board seats. The ruling also limits civil recovery after acquittal and forum shopping in corporate disputes. Directors and trustees are not automatically barred from receiving compensation from their own corporation when they are being paid for actual officer work, management duties, or services separate from […]