When Eyewitness Identification Beats Alibi in Philippine Criminal Cases

Alibi failed against credible eyewitness identification by familiar witnesses; murder conviction stood, but penalties were modified after abolition of death penalty. In criminal trials, an alibi will not save an accused when credible witnesses who knew him beforehand positively identify him as one of the offenders and place him at the scene of the crime. […]

A Lookout Can Be Convicted for the Killing: The Conspiracy Rule in Robbery With Homicide

A lookout in a robbery may be liable for homicide when conspiracy is proven. The ruling explains witness credibility, alibi, flight, and group-crime liability. A person who never entered the house, never fired the fatal shot, and acted only as a lookout may still be convicted for robbery with homicide if the evidence shows that […]

Joining a Robbery Gang Can Make Every Member Liable for the Killing

Group robbery participants may be liable for robbery with homicide when conspiracy is proven, even if they did not personally inflict the fatal wound. A participant in a group robbery may be punished for the killing and injuries committed during the raid even if the prosecution cannot prove that he personally fired the fatal shot. […]

Suspicion Is Not Proof: Why Courts Must Acquit When Eyewitness Identification Leaves Reasonable Doubt

Presence near a crime and uncertain eyewitness identification cannot sustain a murder conviction without proof beyond reasonable doubt. A criminal conviction cannot rest on suspicion, presence near the scene, or an eyewitness account that fails to place the accused as the actual offender with moral certainty. The Quinto ruling reinforces a core protection for every […]

A Guilty Plea Is Not a Shortcut to Conviction: Why Courts Must Still Test the Evidence in Capital Cases

A guilty plea in a capital case does not end judicial scrutiny; courts must still examine evidence, intent, aggravating circumstances, and penalty. A person who pleads guilty to a capital offense is not automatically condemned by that plea alone. Courts must still receive evidence, determine whether the accused understood the charge and consequences, examine aggravating […]

Newly Discovered Evidence Can Reopen a Criminal Conviction When It Casts Serious Doubt on Guilt

Newly discovered evidence may reopen a criminal conviction when it raises serious doubt on guilt and was unavailable at trial without the accused’s fault. A criminal conviction is not necessarily the final word when later evidence shows that the judgment may have rested on an incomplete record. In People v. Gensola, the Supreme Court applied […]