Lawyers Cannot Threaten Judges to Stop Court Orders

Lawyers may challenge court orders, but threatening a judge with criminal or administrative complaints to stop implementation violates professional ethics. A lawyer may challenge a judgeโ€™s order, seek appellate relief, and protect a client with zeal, but advocacy crosses the line when it becomes a threat directed at the judge personally. The ruling teaches a […]

Courts Must Put Orders in Writing: Why Margin Notes Are Not Enough in Criminal Cases

Court rulings on motions must be formally recorded. The judge was reprimanded for using a margin note but cleared on arraignment, counsel, and contempt issues. People facing criminal charges are entitled to more than informal courtroom instructions, handwritten margin notes, or verbal explanations from court staff. When a court grants or denies a motion, especially […]

When a Lower Court Ignores a Restraining Order, the Judge Can Be Personally Sanctioned

A judge who ignored an appellate restraining order stopping demolition was fined for grave abuse, reinforcing obedience to higher court orders. Lower court judges cannot treat appellate restraining orders as optional, even when they believe the order is procedurally defective, unclear, or wrongly issued. The practical consequence is direct and important: once a higher court […]

Ignoring a Court Order Is Not Cured by Partial Payment or Good Intentions

Partial compliance and good faith did not purge contempt where a lawyer failed to fully obey a court order to account for disputed labor-case proceeds. A party held in contempt cannot escape punishment by making partial payment, offering explanations, or invoking good faith after failing to fully obey a clear court directive. The practical lesson […]

Jailed for Contempt Without a Lawyer? Flores Says Habeas Corpus Can Set You Free

A contempt order that jails a person without counsel may be attacked by habeas corpus, especially where property possession facts remain unclear. A person jailed for indirect contempt may be released through habeas corpus when the contempt proceeding violated the constitutional right to counsel. Flores v. Judge Ruiz teaches that contempt may look like a […]

When Sharp Pleadings Become Contempt: What Tax Litigants Should Know About Courtroom Advocacy

A lawyer may challenge an unfair order, but insulting language can be contempt. The Supreme Court lifted an excessive suspension and restored rebuttal evidence. Lawyers and litigants may challenge a judgeโ€™s ruling, even forcefully, but the challenge must remain within the bounds of respect for the court. Calo v. Judge Tapucar draws the line between […]