Courts Cannot Hand Corporate Control to an Outsider by Injunction

Corporate control belongs to the board, not an outside intervenor. The Supreme Court stopped an injunction that handed management to a private claimant. Corporate control cannot be transferred by a trial court to a private outsider merely because that outsider has a contract with someone claiming authority over the corporation. Management of a stock corporation […]

Stockholders Can Enforce Corporate Inspection Rights in the RTC Even When Sequestered Companies Are Involved

Stockholders may enforce inspection rights in the RTC when the dispute is intra-corporate, even if the company has sequestration history. Stockholders and corporate representatives do not lose the ordinary remedy of enforcing inspection rights merely because a corporation has a sequestration history or a factional board dispute. When the controversy is about corporate books, board […]

Corporate Officers Can Be Personally Liable for Bad Faith Management Without Piercing the Corporate Veil

Corporate officers may be personally liable for bad faith or gross negligence under Section 31, even without piercing the corporate veil. Corporate officers cannot hide behind the corporation when they personally manage corporate affairs in bad faith or with gross negligence. A creditor, government agency, stockholder, member, or other injured party may recover damages directly […]

When Corporate Elections Are Contested, the SEC May Still Act

A corporate election case does not stop the SEC from exercising retained regulatory powers, and election contests must be filed within 15 days. A pending corporate election dispute does not automatically freeze all regulatory action involving the corporation. Stockholders and directors fighting over control may go to court over the validity of meetings, elections, or […]

Minority Shareholders Can Sue Directly to Stop Dilution of Their Preemptive Rights

Minority shareholders may sue directly to stop stock issuances that dilute preemptive rights; the action is not necessarily derivative. Minority shareholders do not always need to sue in the name of the corporation when the injury is personal to them. When a stock issuance threatens to dilute a shareholder’s ownership and preemptive rights, the shareholder […]

No Board Seat by Custom: Association Directors Must Be Elected, Not Installed by Practice

Board seats in associations and non-stock corporations must be legally elected; custom or tolerance cannot create a permanent director’s seat. A corporation or homeowners’ association cannot create a permanent board seat through custom, tolerance, or an unapproved amendment to its by-laws. Even long-standing practice does not ripen into a vested right when the seat violates […]

When a Vice President Is Ousted, the Case May Belong to the SEC — Not the Labor Arbiter

Corporate officers elected under by-laws may need to challenge removal as an intra-corporate dispute, not an NLRC illegal dismissal case. Corporate officers who are removed from positions created by a corporation’s by-laws may not always have an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the labor tribunals. Where the dispute is inseparably tied to the election, appointment, […]

Self-Dealing Directors Cannot Lock In Sweetheart Corporate Deals at the Company’s Expense

A self-dealing director could not enforce an unfair exclusive dealership contract against the corporation without proper disclosure, fairness, and ratification. Corporate insiders cannot use their board seat, office, or access to company information to secure a private commercial advantage from the corporation, especially where the contract is unfair, undisclosed, and prejudicial to the company. For […]

When Unpaid Officer Compensation Is Not a Labor Case: Stockholder-Officers Must Sue in the Corporate Forum

Officer-stockholder pay claims tied to corporate office are intracorporate disputes, not ordinary labor cases, and must be filed in the proper forum. A corporate officer who is also a stockholder may not automatically treat unpaid salaries, per diems, allowances, and similar benefits as an ordinary labor claim. When the compensation being claimed is tied to […]