Stockholders Can Demand Corporate Records โ€” Including Tax Documents โ€” When Their Investment Is at Stake

Stockholders may inspect corporate and tax-related records, and officers who unjustifiably refuse access may face prosecution if probable cause exists. Stockholders are not limited to glossy reports or SEC filings when they ask to inspect corporate records. When a corporation refuses or unduly restricts access to books, minutes, business records, and supporting documents, the responsible […]

Minority Stockholders Can Inspect Corporate Records Unless the Corporation Proves Bad Faith

Minority stockholders may inspect corporate books unless the corporation proves bad faith, improper use, or illegitimate purpose. Minority stockholders do not have to prove their good faith before they can inspect corporate books; the corporation that refuses inspection must prove improper motive, bad faith, or illegitimate purpose. That rule matters in tax, corporate governance, and […]

When a Shareholder Demands the Books, Corporations May Ask Why

Shareholders may inspect corporate books only in good faith. Bad-faith demands can defeat probable cause for criminal charges against officers who refuse access. Corporate officers are not automatically criminally liable for refusing a shareholderโ€™s demand to inspect company records when the demand appears to be made in bad faith, for an improper purpose, or to […]

When Informal Payments Are Not Salary: Lessons on Stock Sales, Donations, and Corporate Records

A shareholder who accepted full payment could not undo a stock sale despite irregular records; informal salary claims may be treated as void donations. Corporate shareholders cannot use irregular stock-transfer paperwork to undo a sale they knowingly accepted, especially after receiving the full purchase price and allowing the transaction to stand for years. For business […]

When a Former Lawyer Uses Your Corporate Records Against You

A lawyer may be disciplined for using client information in later corporate disputes, even if he claims to act as a stockholder or insider. A lawyer who turns client confidences into weapons for later disputes can be disciplined even if the lawyer also claims to be acting as a stockholder or corporate insider. The core […]

When Corporate Papers Are Not Proof of Payment: Why Share Buyers Need Receipts and Stock Book Records

Corporate papers and officer titles do not prove share payment or ownership without competent evidence and stock book recording. A person who buys shares in a corporation cannot rely on board resolutions, secretaryโ€™s certificates, or an officer title alone to prove payment or ownership. The controlling lesson is practical and unforgiving: when money changes hands […]

Lost Stock Certificates Are Not Ordinary Civil Claims: Why Stockholders Must Bring Replacement Disputes to the Corporate Forum

A stockholderโ€™s claim for replacement of a missing stock certificate is an intra-corporate controversy, and damages do not move it to ordinary courts. Stockholders who are refused a replacement stock certificate cannot automatically turn that dispute into an ordinary damages case in the regular courts. When the controversy is fundamentally between a stockholder and the […]