When Corporate Factions Sue Too Many Times: The Supreme Courtโ€™s Warning Against Forum Shopping

The Supreme Court clarified forum shopping limits, management committee relief, and voting rules in non-stock corporate leadership disputes. Corporate and association disputes cannot be fought through repeated, overlapping cases in different tribunals just to secure a more favorable ruling. When rival factions recycle the same allegations, parties, and reliefs across multiple proceedings, courts may treat […]

When Courts May Take Over Corporate Books: The Sy Chim Rule on Emergency Audits and Management Committees

Courts may order an independent audit in corporate disputes, but cannot impose a management committee without clear imminent danger to assets. Corporate officers accused of withholding records or mishandling company funds may be subjected to an emergency court-supervised audit even before the main case is decided, but courts cannot immediately take over corporate management unless […]

When a Corporate Officer Faces a Criminal Case, the Victim Can Still Pursue Civil Damages Inside the Same Trial

The Supreme Court allowed private prosecutors to intervene in a corporate falsification case because civil liability was deemed included in the criminal action. A person harmed by alleged corporate falsification may pursue the civil consequences of the crime within the criminal case itself, unless that civil action was waived, reserved, or already filed separately. The […]

Stock Certificates Are Evidence, Not Ownership: Why Share Transfers Can Still Bind Corporate Insiders

Share transfers may bind corporate insiders despite certificate issues when records, conduct, and equity show the transaction was completed and recognized. Corporate insiders cannot defeat a completed stock transfer simply by keeping or refusing to endorse a certificate after the corporation has already recognized the transfer in its books. For shareholders, directors, and family-owned corporations, […]