Refund Doubt Rule: When Tax Errors Defeat a Refund Claim

Tax refunds fail when the same return shows a larger underpayment; the CTA may examine the full return before granting recovery. The Refund Doubt Rule means a taxpayer cannot recover an allegedly overpaid tax when the same return shows a larger underpayment for the same taxable year. For businesses seeking tax refunds in the Philippines, […]

A Stockholder Deposit Is Not Automatically Taxable as a Stock Subscription

A stockholder deposit for possible future shares is not automatically subject to DST, and a tax protest remains valid when supported by relevant taxpayer documents. Corporations facing documentary stamp tax assessments can contest a BIR theory that treats every stockholder advance as a taxable stock subscription, especially when no subscription agreement was executed, no shares […]

Regulatory Fees Must Follow the Statute: Why Agencies Cannot Use Market Value When the Law Says Paid Capital

Regulators may collect statutory supervision fees, but they cannot enlarge the computation base beyond capital stock subscribed or paid, rejecting market-value assessments. Businesses assessed regulatory or supervision fees may challenge the computation when the collecting agency uses a valuation base different from the one fixed by law. The key doctrine is straightforward but powerful: when […]