When Court Criticism Becomes Contempt: The Line Between Legitimate Advocacy and Scurrilous Attacks

The Court fined a complainant for indirect contempt after unfounded attacks on justices, clarifying when strong criticism of court delay becomes punishable. Litigants may criticize judges and court decisions, but they cross into contempt when their language stops being a good-faith challenge to legal error and becomes a scurrilous attack on the integrity of the […]

When Courtroom Criticism Becomes Contempt: Why Judges Cannot Jail Litigants Without the Right Process

Court criticism filed before another office is indirect contempt, not direct contempt, and may be privileged against libel when made in good faith. A litigant who attacks a judge in a complaint filed before another government office may face consequences, but not through summary punishment as direct contempt. The governing principle is procedural: disrespectful language […]