Offline Carrier Tax Treaty Rule: Air Canada Refund Denied

Foreign airlines selling tickets locally may avoid GPB tax, but treaty-limited income tax can still defeat a Philippine tax refund claim. The Offline Carrier Tax Treaty Rule means that a foreign airline selling tickets in the Philippines may escape Gross Philippine Billings tax if it has no Philippine-originating flights, but it can still be treated […]

Offline Airlines Can Be Taxed in the Philippines Even Without Flights Here

Foreign airlines with no Philippine flights may still be taxed here through local ticket sales, but treaty limits apply. Air Canada’s refund was denied. Foreign airlines that do not fly to or from the Philippines may still be treated as doing business here when they sell tickets through a local general sales agent, but their […]

Tax Refund Withdrawal Rule: When CTA Appeals Cannot Be Abandoned

VAT refund claims may fail despite a BIR tax credit when CTA findings, proof defects, or prescription show the refund is unsupported. The Tax Refund Withdrawal Rule protects the public treasury from refund settlements that contradict judicial findings. A taxpayer cannot always end a Court of Tax Appeals case simply because the BIR later issued […]

CWT Refund Proof Rule: Annual ITR Can Win a Tax Refund

Annual ITR evidence may prove no CWT carry-over, allowing taxpayers to recover valid refunds despite missing quarterly returns. The CWT Refund Proof Rule protects taxpayers from losing valid refund claims merely because they did not present every quarterly return, so long as they can prove by competent evidence that excess creditable withholding taxes were not […]

Tax Treaty Refund Rule: BIR Prior Filing Cannot Defeat Relief

Treaty-rate tax refunds cannot be denied solely for missed prior BIR filing when entitlement is proven and refund claims are timely filed. Taxpayers who overpaid withholding tax because they failed to apply a treaty rate in time may still recover the excess tax if they are genuinely entitled to treaty relief. The Tax Treaty Refund […]

Tax Refund Evidence Rule: How Companies Prove Excess CWT Claims

Companies may recover excess CWT if timely filed and proven; BIR cannot defeat a refund claim without rebutting the taxpayer’s evidence. Corporate taxpayers claiming a refund of excess creditable withholding tax must prove three things clearly: timely filing, declaration of the related income, and actual withholding by the payor. The Tax Refund Evidence Rule matters […]

Tax Refund Claimants Need Not Prove BIR Remittance When Withholding Certificates Are Complete

Complete withholding tax certificates can support a refund claim; taxpayers need not prove actual BIR remittance by withholding agents. Taxpayers claiming a refund of excess creditable withholding tax do not have to prove that the withholding agent actually remitted the tax to the BIR, so long as they present complete withholding tax certificates executed under […]

Tax Refunds Have a Hard Two-Year Deadline Even When the BIR Confirms the Exemption Later

A BIR ruling confirming tax exemption does not restart the two-year tax refund period; refund claims still run from tax payment date. Taxpayers and withholding agents cannot wait for a later BIR ruling before counting the deadline to recover taxes already paid. When a tax has been erroneously or excessively paid, the two-year period to […]

When a Tax Exemption Covers Indirect Taxes, the Buyer May Claim the Refund

The Supreme Court allowed PAL to claim a refund of passed-on excise taxes because its franchise clearly exempted it from direct and indirect taxes. A company that is expressly exempt from both direct and indirect taxes may recover excise taxes passed on to it as part of a purchase price, even if another party was […]