Tax Demurrer Acquittal Rule: When BIR Tax Charges Fail

Criminal tax acquittals after demurrer are final unless grave abuse is shown, but civil tax liability may still proceed separately. The Tax Demurrer Acquittal Rule gives accused taxpayers and corporate officers powerful protection: once a criminal tax case is dismissed after the prosecution’s evidence fails, the acquittal is generally final, and the government cannot use […]

Asset Sale Non-Merger Rule: Tax Liability After Bank Acquisitions

Asset buyers are not liable for seller tax debts when the deal is an asset sale, not merger, and only identified liabilities were assumed. The asset sale non-merger rule protects an acquiring corporation from being made liable for another corporation’s tax debts when the transaction is, by its clear terms, only a sale of identified […]

Prospective Tax Rules: Why Old BIR Regulations Still Control

Tax rules apply prospectively: later BIR regulations cannot defeat earlier assessments unless retroactivity is clearly allowed by law. Businesses cannot avoid a tax assessment by relying on a later, more favorable revenue regulation when the taxable period was governed by an earlier rule. The Prospective Tax Rules Doctrine means that tax laws and implementing regulations […]

Tax Refund Proof Rule: When Corporate Overpayments Must Be Credited

Corporate tax overpayments must be refunded or credited when supported by substantial evidence; BIR objections alone cannot defeat the claim. The tax refund proof rule protects corporate taxpayers from being denied a refund merely because the Bureau of Internal Revenue wants more detail after the taxpayer has already presented substantial tax returns, payment records, and […]

Tax Fraud Penalty Rule: Why Underdeclared Income Is Not Enough

Tax fraud penalties require proof of intentional evasion; underdeclared income alone may support assessment but not the 50% fraud surcharge. Under the tax fraud penalty rule, a large deficiency assessment may keep the government within the longer collection period, but it does not automatically justify the 50 percent fraud surcharge. For taxpayers, heirs, executors, and […]