Tax Evasion Charges Can Prescribe If Prosecutors File the Information Too Late

Criminal tax charges for willful failure to pay VAT prescribed because the Information was filed in court beyond the five-year NIRC period. Taxpayers facing criminal tax cases may defeat prosecution where the government allows the five-year prescriptive period to lapse before filing the Information in court, even if a complaint for preliminary investigation was earlier […]

Taxpayers Can Cut BIR Assessments Based on Unverified Preprocessed Data

Taxpayer reduced a BIR assessment after unverified preprocessed data, prescribed VAT items, and compromise penalties were struck down, though income tax and VAT remained due. Taxpayers facing BIR assessments based on unverified third-party or preprocessed data should examine whether the alleged undeclared sales were actually confirmed, whether the assessment was issued within the prescriptive period, […]

Invalid Tax Protests Can Cost Taxpayers Their Day in Tax Court

A defective BIR protest led to dismissal of a tax appeal because no valid disputed assessment existed for Court of Tax Appeals review. Taxpayers facing a BIR Final Assessment Notice must file a protest that strictly states whether it is a request for reconsideration or reinvestigation, identifies the date of the assessment notice, and sets […]

Invalid LOA and Unproven Assessment Notices Can Defeat BIR Tax Assessments

A BIR assessment failed after the Commissioner could not prove valid audit authority or actual receipt of PAN, FLD, and FAN notices by the taxpayer. Taxpayers facing BIR deficiency tax assessments should closely examine two threshold issues before arguing the numbers: whether the revenue officer had a valid Letter of Authority and whether the assessment […]

Expired Assessment Periods Can Void Deficiency Tax Assessments Despite BIR Quarantine Extensions

Tax court denied reconsideration after finding key BIR assessments prescribed and unsupported by specific factual bases despite quarantine extension arguments. Taxpayers facing deficiency tax assessments should closely check both the original and extended assessment deadlines because a Formal Letter of Demand served after prescription may be cancelled even if the BIR invokes pandemic-era suspension rules. […]

PDR Tax Prosecution Fails Without Proof of Dealer Status or Taxable Gain

PDR tax prosecution failed after the court found no dealer activity, taxable gain, VAT liability, or civil tax liability from the disputed transactions. Tax prosecutions arising from alleged unreported Philippine Depositary Receipt transactions cannot succeed unless the government first proves the basic tax premise: that the taxpayer was actually acting as a dealer in securities, […]

No 10-Year Tax Assessment Period Without Proof of Fraudulent Return

A tax accused remained free from civil liability because the CTA found no proven fraudulent return and the deficiency income tax assessments for 2009 and 2010 had prescribed. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges may still defeat a related civil claim for unpaid taxes when the government cannot prove that the return was fraudulent or false […]

BIR Assessments Can Be Voided When the FLD Ignores the Taxpayer’s PAN Reply

A 2015 BIR assessment was cancelled after the FLD repeated the PAN without addressing the taxpayer’s reply, violating due process under Section 228. Taxpayers facing a BIR deficiency tax assessment should carefully preserve and document every reply, protest, and supporting document submitted during audit because an assessment may be cancelled when the BIR issues a […]

BIR Capital Gains Tax Assessments Can Be Cancelled When Issued After Prescription

The tax court cancelled a Php355.48M CGT assessment after finding the BIR assessed too late and failed to prove a deliberate false return. Taxpayers facing old BIR assessments should carefully check prescription before debating the tax computation itself. In a major capital gains tax assessment dispute, the Court of Tax Appeals cancelled a Php355.48 million […]

Tax Collection Orders Can Be Reversed When the BIR Acts Too Late or Relies Only on Assessments

The tax court reversed a P51.2M civil tax payment order after finding prescription and lack of competent proof of unpaid taxes in a criminal tax case. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges should not assume that an acquittal automatically ends the financial exposure, but this ruling shows that the government must still prove and timely pursue […]