Criminal Tax Cases for Nonpayment Can Be Dismissed When the Government Files Too Late

Criminal tax charges for failure to pay were dismissed after the Information was filed beyond the five-year NIRC prescriptive period. Taxpayers facing criminal charges for alleged failure to pay assessed taxes should examine prescription immediately, because even a final and demandable tax assessment will not indefinitely keep a criminal tax case alive. In this Resolution, […]

Tax Appeals Can Be Lost on Filing Compliance, Not Just Assessment Merits

Late email transmittal of a tax appeal motion led the court to deem it not filed, reinforcing strict filing compliance in BIR assessment disputes. Taxpayers challenging BIR assessments before the Court of Tax Appeals must treat electronic transmittal requirements as jurisdiction-sensitive litigation deadlines: a motion for reconsideration filed in hard copy may still be treated […]

Tax Refund Appeals Can Be Lost When Petitions Are Sent by Courier Instead of Properly Filed

A tax refund appeal was dismissed because the initiatory petition sent by courier was deemed filed only upon actual court receipt, after the deadline. Taxpayers appealing a denied refund or tax credit claim before the Court of Tax Appeals must treat the mode of filing as jurisdictional: an initiatory petition sent through an accredited courier […]

VAT Refunds for Zero-Rated Sales Can Fail Without Proof the Service Contract Covered the Taxable Quarter

Input VAT refund denied after taxpayer failed to prove valid zero-rated sales for the covered quarter despite timely filing and VAT registration. VAT-registered taxpayers seeking refunds or tax credit certificates for input VAT attributable to zero-rated sales must prove not only that their customer is legally entitled to zero-rating, but also that the specific sales […]

Defective FDDA Can Be Cancelled Without Voiding the BIR Assessment

A defective FDDA cancelled the decision but not the valid FLD; the taxpayer still owed P47.1M, while compromise penalties were cancelled. Taxpayers who receive a defective Final Decision on Disputed Assessment may still face collection if the underlying Formal Letter of Demand and assessment notices are valid. In this 2014 assessment dispute, the taxpayer succeeded […]

BIR Tax Assessments Can Be Voided When Revenue Officers Lack a Proper Letter of Authority

A tax assessment may be void when BIR officers who conducted the audit lack a valid Letter of Authority, even if the issue is raised later in litigation. Taxpayers facing deficiency withholding tax assessments should closely examine whether the revenue officers who conducted the audit were specifically authorized by a valid Letter of Authority, because […]

BIR Tax Assessments Can Be Voided When Reassigned Auditors Lack a New Letter of Authority

Tax assessments may be void when reassigned BIR officers audit without a new LOA; the court denied reconsideration and affirmed the taxpayer’s win. Taxpayers facing deficiency tax assessments should closely examine whether the revenue officers who actually conducted the audit were named in a valid Letter of Authority, because an assessment built on an unauthorized […]

Taxpayers Facing BIR Summons Charges Can Challenge Defective Subpoenas

A taxpayer was acquitted after the tax court found reasonable doubt that the BIR properly issued the subpoena underlying a Section 266 summons charge. A taxpayer accused of failing to obey a BIR summons may still defeat a criminal tax case when the subpoena duces tecum was not properly issued under the BIR’s own procedural […]

Taxpayers Get More Room to Challenge Collection When BIR Skips a Clear Final Decision

Taxpayers may challenge BIR collection after a warrant if no clear FDDA was issued, and the BIR cannot belatedly invoke the 10-year period without due process. Taxpayers facing BIR collection notices should not automatically assume that every preliminary collection letter starts the 30-day countdown to appeal. When the BIR fails to clearly issue a final […]