When Tax Deductions Survive BIR Challenge: Atlas and the Business Expense Rule for Corporate Taxpayers

Atlas clarifies when corporate expenses are deductible, allowing investor and listing-related costs but treating title-defense litigation expenses as capital costs. Corporate taxpayers may deduct expenses that genuinely serve the business even when the benefit is indirect, reputational, or investor-facing, but they cannot turn capital-preserving litigation costs into ordinary deductions. The Atlas ruling remains important because […]

When Customs Seizes Goods, Ordinary Courts Cannot Take Them Back

Customs forfeiture disputes belong before customs authorities and the Court of Tax Appeals, not ordinary trial courts through replevin or garnishment. Importers and businesses facing customs seizure or forfeiture cannot bypass the customs process by filing replevin, damages, or garnishment actions in an ordinary trial court. Once the dispute concerns goods seized and forfeited under […]

When a Tax Exemption Is Clear, Courts Must Enforce It Even Against the Government

Clear tax exemptions must be enforced as written; MERALCO recovered special import tax after insulating oil was treated as an exempt insulator. Tax exemptions are usually read strictly against the taxpayer, but that rule has an important limit: when the exemption is written in clear and unambiguous language, courts may not narrow it by interpretation. […]

When Tax Penalties Start After a Court-Modified Assessment

Court-modified tax assessments trigger surcharge only after finality and nonpayment within 30 days, but taxpayers and heirs remain liable for penalties. Taxpayers who lose a tax case after the court modifies the BIR assessment do not automatically owe delinquency penalties from the original assessment date; the decisive date is when the judgment fixing the final […]

Meralco’s Franchise Tax Exemption Did Not Shield Imported Equipment from Compensating Tax

Meralco’s franchise did not exempt imported equipment from compensating tax because tax exemptions must be clear and strictly construed against taxpayers. A taxpayer claiming exemption from Philippine taxes must point to clear, unmistakable language granting that privilege; broad franchise phrases such as “in lieu of all taxes” will not erase taxes that the law and […]

Tax Exemptions Are Narrow: Why Businesses Cannot Stretch an Incentive Beyond Its Exact Terms

A tax exemption covers only what it clearly says. The Court upheld BIR assessments where a manufacturer expanded beyond its exempt activity. A tax exemption certificate does not give a business a free pass from all related taxes. When an exemption is granted for a specific activity, product, or industry, the taxpayer must stay within […]

Tax Exemptions Do Not Travel by Implication: Why a Rival’s Government Tax Break Won’t Automatically Lower Your Customs Bill

A private utility cannot borrow NPC’s tax exemption by implication; exemptions must be clear, express, and granted to the taxpayer itself. A private utility cannot claim a tax or customs exemption merely because a government corporation operating in the same general field enjoys one. For businesses importing equipment, materials, or supplies, the lesson is direct: […]

When a Business Cannot Refund a Tax It Already Passed On to Customers

A seller cannot recover a tax refund for amounts separately charged to customers, even if the tax was improper, because the buyers bore the burden. A business that separately charges tax to its customers cannot ordinarily recover that tax for itself, even if the tax later turns out to have been legally improper. The controlling […]

When Real Property Tax Assessments Can Be Challenged Without Paying First

Real property tax assessments may be challenged without prior payment when legality is disputed, and void assessments may support refund relief. A taxpayer disputing a real property tax assessment may challenge the legality or validity of that assessment before the tax tribunals without first paying the tax under protest, and if the assessment is void, […]

Capital Improvements Can Reduce Taxable Gain Even If Paid After the Sale

Capital improvements may reduce taxable gain even if paid later, when the obligation arose and the services increased the property’s value before sale. Property sellers may reduce taxable gain by including capital improvements in the property’s cost basis when those improvements increased the value of the property and the obligation to pay arose before or […]