Court Employees Cannot Hand Case Evidence to a Party’s Relative

Court staff may be disciplined for giving disputed evidence to a party’s relative, even without proof of tampering, if the act compromises court neutrality. Judicial personnel who handle court records, subpoenas, and documentary evidence are not mere clerical actors; they are custodians of the court’s neutrality. When a court employee gives disputed evidence to a […]

Court Staff Cannot Send You to Jail Without a Judge’s Order

Court clerks cannot order arrests or detention without judicial authority; doing so is grave misconduct punishable by dismissal and benefit forfeiture. A clerk of court has no power to order a person arrested, detained, or jailed simply because that person was convicted or intended to appeal. Arrest, detention, and commitment to jail are judicial acts […]

When Court Officers Abuse Public Trust: Why Misconduct Can Destroy a Judgment Enforcement Career

Court sheriffs may be dismissed for repeated drunkenness, unauthorized absences, misconduct, and unlicensed firearm possession despite unresolved criminal issues. Government employees who enforce court orders cannot treat public office as a private privilege: repeated drunkenness, unauthorized absences, disorderly conduct, and carrying an unlicensed firearm may justify dismissal, forfeiture of benefits, and permanent disqualification from government […]

Fraudulent Foreclosure Papers Cannot Support a Deficiency Claim

Altered foreclosure sale papers defeated a bank’s deficiency claim, lifted an attachment, and led to dismissal of court personnel for misconduct. A party who ignores obvious warning signs in foreclosure documents cannot later use the courts to collect a deficiency as if nothing happened. In Dinsay, the Supreme Court treated altered auction papers, suspicious bid […]

Government Employees Can Be Disciplined for Refusing to Pay Just Debts

Government employees may face administrative discipline for willfully refusing to pay admitted just debts, even if the dispute is civil and no criminal case prospers. Public office does not end at the courthouse door: a government employee who willfully refuses to pay a just debt may face administrative discipline even when the underlying transaction is […]

Sheriffs Cannot Overreach During Execution: The Prudence Rule for Seized Property

Sheriffs enforcing writs must act with prudence and caution. Improper seizure of disputed property may lead to sanctions despite later reimbursement. Winning a case does not give officers enforcing the judgment a free hand to seize property whose ownership or source is uncertain. Court sheriffs must enforce writs of execution with prudence, caution, and attention […]

Court Staff Can Be Disciplined for Rude Phone Conduct, Even When Dismissal Is Too Harsh

Court personnel may be reprimanded for discourteous phone conduct, but dismissal requires clearer proof of serious unfitness and a proportionate penalty. Discourtesy by court personnel can become an administrative offense even when it occurs in a brief telephone exchange, but dismissal from government service requires a clearer and more serious showing of unfitness than a […]

Government Employees Can Be Disciplined for Losing Their Temper at Work, Even When Provoked

Public employees may be disciplined for indecorous office conduct even when provoked, while complainants can also face scrutiny for their role. Public employees who are provoked at work do not get a free pass to turn a government office into a public confrontation. The ruling in Atienza v. Perez makes clear that court personnel, and […]