Temperate Advocacy Rule: When Harsh Pleadings Become Contempt

Lawyers may criticize rulings, but offensive pleadings imputing gross ignorance to a court may constitute direct contempt under Philippine law. The Temperate Advocacy Rule reminds litigants and lawyers that zealous advocacy has a hard boundary: pleadings may attack legal errors, but they may not denigrate the court itself. In Philippine litigation, an intemperate motion can […]

When Sharp Pleadings Become Contempt: What Tax Litigants Should Know About Courtroom Advocacy

A lawyer may challenge an unfair order, but insulting language can be contempt. The Supreme Court lifted an excessive suspension and restored rebuttal evidence. Lawyers and litigants may challenge a judgeโ€™s ruling, even forcefully, but the challenge must remain within the bounds of respect for the court. Calo v. Judge Tapucar draws the line between […]