When Court Delay Is Not Neglect: The Supreme Courtโ€™s Practical Rule on eRaffle Backlogs and Administrative Liability

Court eRaffle delays do not automatically prove neglect; liability requires carelessness, bad faith, or breach of duty, but false surety clearances may still be punishable. Judges and court personnel are not automatically administratively liable simply because a new court technology causes case raffle delays. The decisive question is whether the delay was caused by carelessness, […]

Case Raffles Must Be Real: Why Judges Cannot Handpick Cases Even for Speed

Judges cannot bypass mandatory case raffles for convenience. Directly assigning cases to one branch undermines impartiality and may lead to discipline. Courts cannot sacrifice the neutrality of case raffles in the name of convenience, speed, or even a seemingly practical concern for accused persons seeking provisional liberty. When a judge directly assigns cases to his […]

A Judge Cannot Force an Unrepresented Accused to Cross-Examine Witnesses

A judge was severely censured for forcing a non-lawyer accused to cross-examine witnesses and ordering reimbursement under threat of contempt. Courts may move cases forward, but speed cannot come at the expense of basic fairness: an accused person who is not a lawyer cannot be compelled to conduct his own cross-examination merely because his counsel […]