Drug Convictions Can Fall When the Chain of Custody Breaks After Laboratory Testing

Drug convictions were reversed after gaps in the chain of custody left reasonable doubt on whether the shabu presented in court was the same evidence seized. Accused persons in drug cases may be acquitted even after a buy-bust operation, laboratory confirmation, and prior conviction when the prosecution cannot prove every critical handoff of the seized […]

Suspicion Is Not Proof: Why Weak Circumstantial Evidence Cannot Sustain a Murder Conviction

Suspicion and vague conduct cannot sustain a murder conviction. The Supreme Court acquitted Mariano because the circumstantial evidence failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. A person accused of a serious crime cannot be convicted merely because the surrounding facts look suspicious. In Mariano, the Supreme Court reaffirmed a bedrock rule of criminal litigation: circumstantial […]

When a Witness Takes Back Testimony: New Trial Rules in Philippine Criminal Cases

Witness recantation can justify a new trial when the conviction rests solely on that witness and special circumstances cast doubt on the original testimony. A criminal conviction may be reopened when the witness who supplied the only direct identification later retracts that testimony and special circumstances show that the original identification may have been unreliable. […]

When Minor Inconsistencies Cannot Defeat a Child Trafficking Conviction

The Supreme Court affirmed a qualified trafficking conviction, holding that transporting, offering, and arranging a child for sexual exploitation is punishable. A person who arranges, transports, introduces, or offers a child to clients for sexual services may be convicted of qualified trafficking even if the child was first introduced by someone else, even if payment […]

OSG Appellate Counsel Rule: Criminal Appeals Need State Due Process

Criminal appeals require notice to the OSG; an acquittal issued without State due process may be void and remanded. The OSG Appellate Counsel Rule means that an accused cannot secure an appellate acquittal in a criminal case without giving the People of the Philippines, through the Office of the Solicitor General, a fair opportunity to […]

When a Victim’s Testimony Can Sustain a Rape Conviction Despite Imperfect Medical Evidence

The Court affirmed four rape convictions but reduced the penalty because qualifying circumstances were not properly alleged and proven. A rape conviction may stand on the credible, straightforward testimony of the victim even when the medical findings do not perfectly match the accused’s theory of what “should” have appeared after the assault. For persons involved […]

When a Criminal Conviction Fails Because Doubt Remains: The Payopay Rule on Testimony, Medical Evidence, and Uncharged Offenses

The Supreme Court reversed a rape conviction where testimony, medical evidence, and charging defects left reasonable doubt and barred conviction for an uncharged offense. A criminal conviction cannot rest on sympathy, suspicion, or even a plausible accusation when material gaps in the prosecution’s story leave reasonable doubt. Payopay is a reminder that the testimony of […]

When Rape Is Not Proven but Sexual Abuse Still Is: Why Inconsistent Testimony Can Reduce a Conviction

Rape conviction was reduced to acts of lasciviousness where material inconsistencies and an inadmissible custodial admission left reasonable doubt. A rape conviction cannot stand when the prosecution’s own evidence leaves reasonable doubt on the essential facts of penetration and the victim’s state of consciousness, but the accused may still be convicted of a lesser included […]

When a Victim’s Credible Testimony Is Enough to Convict in Rape Cases

A credible rape victim’s testimony may sustain conviction even without decisive medical findings, but qualifying circumstances must be properly alleged. A rape conviction may stand on the testimony of the victim alone when that testimony is credible, natural, convincing, and consistent with human experience. For an accused person, the ruling is a warning that denial […]

A Rape Conviction Can Stand on Credible Testimony, But Death Penalty Requires Strict Proof of Qualifying Facts

Credible victim testimony sustained three rape convictions, but the death penalty was reduced because minority and relationship were not properly alleged and proven. In rape prosecutions, a victim’s credible and consistent testimony may be enough to convict, even without extensive physical injuries or conclusive medical findings. But if the State seeks the death penalty or […]