Rape Convictions Cannot Rest on a Theory the Accused Was Never Required to Defend Against

Rape conviction reversed because the prosecution failed to prove the charged mode of force or intimidation and could not rely on an uncharged theory. A criminal conviction must stand or fall on the charge actually made, not on a different theory discovered only after trial. In People v. Mendigurin, the Supreme Court acquitted an accused […]

When Conviction Stands but the Death Penalty Falls: Why Relationship Must Be Strictly Proven in Rape Cases

Rape conviction affirmed, but death penalty reduced because the qualifying relationship was not strictly alleged and proven under criminal law. A rape conviction may rest on the clear, credible, and detailed testimony of the victim, but a higher penalty cannot be imposed unless every qualifying circumstance is both properly alleged and independently proven. For accused […]

When the Charge Is Defective, the Penalty Cannot Be Upgraded After Trial

The Supreme Court affirmed murder and rape convictions but reduced penalties where homicide was not alleged in the rape information. A criminal conviction may stand even when the accusedโ€™s defense fails, but the penalty cannot be increased for a graver crime unless the charging document itself alleges the facts that make that graver crime punishable. […]

A Rape Conviction Can Stand on the Victimโ€™s Testimony Alone โ€” But Death Penalty Allegations Must Be Strictly Proved

Credible victim testimony may sustain rape conviction, but death-penalty facts like age and relationship must be strictly alleged and proven. A person accused of rape may be convicted on the credible testimony of the victim alone, even without medical findings of physical resistance, but aggravating facts that increase the penalty must be alleged and proven […]

A Guilty Plea Is Not Enough in Death Penalty Cases: Why Courts Must Still Hear Evidence

A guilty plea in a capital case cannot support conviction alone; courts must conduct a searching inquiry and require prosecution evidence before judgment. An accused person who pleads guilty to a capital offense cannot be convicted on that plea alone. In the most serious criminal cases, the court must still conduct a searching inquiry, require […]

When a Childโ€™s Testimony Is Not Enough: Reasonable Doubt Can Still Overturn a Rape Conviction

The Supreme Court acquitted an accused father after finding child testimony, alleged coaching, and conflicting medical evidence insufficient to prove rape beyond reasonable doubt. A criminal conviction cannot stand on sympathy, suspicion, or the seriousness of the accusation alone. Even in rape cases involving a young child, the prosecution must still prove guilt beyond reasonable […]

Rape Convictions Can Rest on Credible Testimony Despite Silence, Delay, or a Claimed Romance

Credible victim testimony can sustain a rape conviction despite silence, delay, minor inconsistencies, or a claimed romance, with damages corrected on appeal. A rape conviction may stand on the credible, natural, and consistent testimony of the victim even when she did not shout, immediately run for help, or behave in the way outsiders expect a […]

A Conviction Cannot Stand on a Hollow Decision or an Abandoned Defense

A rape conviction was set aside because the trial court issued a hollow decision and the accused was denied meaningful counsel and due process. A criminal conviction, even in a grave case involving a child, cannot survive if the trial court fails to explain the facts and law supporting guilt and if the accused is […]

When Age Is Not Proven, a Rape Conviction May Stand but the Death Penalty Cannot

A rape conviction may stand on credible victim testimony, but the higher penalty for statutory rape requires competent proof of the victimโ€™s age. A rape conviction may rest on the credible testimony of the victim, but the harsher penalty for statutory rape involving a child below twelve cannot be imposed unless the prosecution proves the […]

A Guilty Plea Does Not Automatically Justify the Death Penalty When the Information Fails to Allege Qualifying Circumstances

The Court affirmed rape convictions but reduced the death penalty because minority and relationship were not alleged in the informations. An accused may admit guilt, and the evidence may strongly show a grave offense, but a court cannot impose the highest possible penalty unless the facts that legally justify that penalty were clearly alleged in […]