A Minor Wound Can Still Mean Murder: Conspiracy Liability in Group Attacks

A group attacker may be liable for murder even if his own wound was not fatal when conspiracy and treachery are proven beyond reasonable doubt. A person who joins a coordinated group attack may be held liable for murder even if the wounds personally attributed to him appear minor. The decisive question is not whether […]

When a Witness Identifies an Accused Only After a Police Lineup, Courts Must Demand More

A conviction for robbery with homicide was reversed because the witness identification was unreliable and the alleged confession was uncorroborated. Criminal conviction cannot rest on a doubtful identification or an uncorroborated confession, especially when the accused faces the gravest penalties. For persons charged in criminal cases, the ruling in People v. Robles reinforces a core […]

A Guilty Plea in a Murder Case Does Not End the Courtโ€™s Duty to Test the Evidence

A guilty plea in murder must still be tested by evidence, especially where confessions, aggravating circumstances, and severe penalties are involved. Even when an accused admits guilt in open court, a judge must still proceed with exceptional care in serious criminal cases: the plea may support conviction, but the record must show that the accused […]

Eyewitness Testimony Can Convict Even Without Motive or Perfect Alibi

Positive identification by credible witnesses can defeat alibi and lack of motive defenses in murder cases, especially when physical impossibility is not proven. A criminal conviction may stand even when the defense attacks the witnessโ€™s exact vantage point, claims lack of motive, or presents an alibi, if the courts find that the accused were positively […]

When a Sudden Stab Becomes Murder: Treachery, Defense of a Relative, and Voluntary Surrender in Philippine Criminal Cases

A sudden knife attack during a scuffle was murder, not justified defense of a relative, where treachery was proven and voluntary surrender was rejected on appeal. A person who joins a fight to protect a relative cannot automatically claim justification if the evidence shows that the supposed victim-relative was not under unlawful aggression, and a […]

When a Criminal Case Can Be Revived Without a New Information

A provisional criminal dismissal with the accusedโ€™s consent may be revived without a new information if the order clearly lacks finality. A criminal case provisionally dismissed with the accusedโ€™s express consent may still be revived without filing a new information, so long as the dismissal order itself makes clear that it is not final and […]

When Alibi Fails: Positive Identification and Unobjected Confessions in Criminal Trials

Alibi failed against credible identification and medical evidence; the Court also treated an unobjected confession as admissible in affirming conviction. Alibi is one of the weakest defenses in a criminal case when the victim personally identifies the accused and the surrounding evidence points to guilt. In People v. De Jesus, the Court affirmed a rape […]