When a Case Transfer Becomes Moot: Why Jurisdiction Can Return to the Civil Courts

A transfer to a military tribunal became moot after a later directive restored civil court jurisdiction, leaving the case for trial on the merits. Criminal cases that were ordered transferred to a military tribunal may return to the civil courts when a later government directive removes the legal basis for military jurisdiction. For litigants, the […]

When a Guilty Plea Is Not Enough: Courts Must Still Test Confessions, Arrests, and Evidence in Capital Criminal Cases

A guilty plea in a grave criminal case must still be tested through inquiry, evidence, and procedure; the conviction was affirmed despite arrest and confession challenges. A guilty plea in a grave criminal case does not end the court’s duty to examine whether the accused understood the charge, whether the confession was voluntary, whether the […]

When a Charge Names the Wrong Law: Why Courts Cannot Dismiss If the Facts Still Show a Crime

A wrong legal label will not automatically defeat a criminal case if the information’s facts still allege conduct punishable by law. Criminal cases should not be thrown out merely because the prosecutor cited the wrong or incomplete legal provision, if the facts alleged in the information clearly describe an act punishable by law. For accused […]

A Guilty Plea Is Not a Shortcut to Conviction: Why Courts Must Still Test the Evidence in Capital Cases

A guilty plea in a capital case does not end judicial scrutiny; courts must still examine evidence, intent, aggravating circumstances, and penalty. A person who pleads guilty to a capital offense is not automatically condemned by that plea alone. Courts must still receive evidence, determine whether the accused understood the charge and consequences, examine aggravating […]

Directly Filed Libel Complaints Can Still Move Forward in Court

A libel complaint directly filed in court may proceed when no fiscal investigation has been conducted, despite an earlier suspended complaint before the fiscal. A criminal complaint does not necessarily die simply because a similar complaint was earlier brought before the fiscal. Where no preliminary investigation has yet been conducted, a court of first instance […]

When a Criminal Appeal Reaches Life Imprisonment, the Appellate Court Must First Decide the Case

Appellate courts must issue a full judgment before elevating criminal cases involving reclusion perpetua or death to the Supreme Court. An accused person whose appeal may result in reclusion perpetua or death is entitled to a complete appellate judgment before the case is elevated to the Supreme Court. The doctrine is simple but important: certification […]

Delayed Reporting Does Not Defeat a Rape Prosecution When Fear Explains the Silence

Delay in reporting rape does not automatically create doubt when fear explains the silence and the complainant’s testimony remains clear and credible. A victim’s delay in reporting sexual assault does not, by itself, create reasonable doubt when the delay is explained by fear, threats, age, or the realities of trauma. In People v. Tampus, the […]

When Local Courts May Still Investigate Libel Complaints Despite Special Venue Rules

Venue rules for libel complaints do not automatically remove a trial court’s authority to conduct preliminary investigation and determine probable cause. A person accused of libel cannot automatically stop a preliminary investigation merely because the complaint was filed in a Court of First Instance rather than before a city fiscal or local prosecutor. For lawyers, […]