BIR Garnishment Fails When Collection Is Filed Years Too Late

A taxpayer defeated BIR collection after the court held that the garnishment was issued beyond the three-year collection period and the assessments remained void. Taxpayers facing bank garnishment for old deficiency tax assessments may still challenge the BIR’s right to collect when the statutory collection period has already expired, even if the assessment itself is […]

Makati Business Tax Refunds Remain Available When the City Reopens the Same Tax Year

Taxpayers may still recover overpaid Makati business tax when the city reopens the same taxable year and its own revised assessment shows an overpayment. Local business taxpayers that paid a city assessment are not automatically barred from seeking a refund if the local treasurer later reopens the same taxable year, conducts another assessment, and effectively […]

Mining Excise Tax Exemptions Fail Without Clear Proof of the FTAA Recovery Period

Mining FTAA contractor lost its 2013 excise tax dispute after failing to prove that the year fell within its tax-exempt recovery period. Mining contractors under financial or technical assistance agreements cannot rely on a self-declared start of commercial production to postpone excise tax liability unless their evidence also accounts for the commercial-operation date stated in […]

Taxpayers Can Cut BIR Assessments When Third-Party Data and Imputed Sales Are Not Properly Verified

CTA reduced a BIR assessment from over P101M to P27.64M, rejecting unverified third-party data and imputed importation sales but sustaining unsupported items. Businesses facing BIR deficiency tax assessments should not assume that every discrepancy from third-party matching, importation records, or accounting schedules automatically creates taxable income or VAT liability. In this assessment dispute, the taxpayer […]

Taxpayers Can Recover Excess Creditable Withholding Tax Without Proving Actual BIR Remittance

Corporate taxpayers may recover excess CWT with valid BIR Form 2307 proof, timely filing, and proper refund election without proving actual remittance. Corporations seeking a refund or tax credit certificate for excess creditable withholding tax should focus on proving three things: timely filing, valid withholding certificates, and inclusion of the related income in the tax […]

BIR Assessments Can Be Voided When the NIC and PAN Are Not Validly Served

A tax assessment remained void after the BIR failed to prove valid service of the NIC and PAN, and its reconsideration motion was dismissed as pro forma. Taxpayers facing deficiency tax assessments should closely examine whether the BIR validly served the Notice of Informal Conference and Preliminary Assessment Notice, because unsupported claims of service will […]

Criminal Tax Evasion Case Dismissed After Prosecutors Failed to Allege the Basic Tax Amount

Criminal tax evasion case dismissed because the Information failed to allege the basic tax amount needed for CTA jurisdiction. Taxpayers facing criminal tax evasion charges should scrutinize the Information itself because a large alleged deficiency tax figure may still be insufficient to place the case within the Court of Tax Appeals’ original jurisdiction if the […]

Jet Fuel Excise Tax Refunds: Court Allows P207.8M Tax Credit for Sales to Qualified International Carriers

Court partly allowed a P207.8M excise tax credit for Jet A-1 fuel sold to qualified international carriers, emphasizing strict proof of refund conditions. Fuel importers and petroleum manufacturers selling Jet A-1 fuel to international air carriers may recover excise taxes previously paid, but only to the extent they can prove every statutory condition: timely refund […]

Cooperatives Cannot Rely on BIR Certificates Alone to Defeat VAT, EWT, and DST Assessments

A cooperative avoided income tax and compromise penalties, but remained liable for VAT, EWT, and DST after failing to prove member-only exempt transactions. Registered cooperatives facing BIR audits cannot be assessed income tax merely because their tax exemption certificate was renewed late, but they must still prove the factual basis for VAT, withholding tax, and […]

Excess CWT Refunds Require Traceable Income Records, Not Proof of BIR Remittance

Excess CWT refund claims need traceable income records, but taxpayers need not prove actual BIR remittance by withholding agents. Taxpayers claiming a refund or tax credit certificate for excess creditable withholding tax must be ready to trace each withholding certificate to income actually reported in the annual income tax return; however, they do not need […]