When Rape Is Not Proven but Sexual Abuse Still Is: Why Inconsistent Testimony Can Reduce a Conviction

Rape conviction was reduced to acts of lasciviousness where material inconsistencies and an inadmissible custodial admission left reasonable doubt. A rape conviction cannot stand when the prosecution’s own evidence leaves reasonable doubt on the essential facts of penetration and the victim’s state of consciousness, but the accused may still be convicted of a lesser included […]

When Identification Is Uncertain, Even a Confession Cannot Save a Criminal Conviction

The Supreme Court acquitted accused persons where identification was unreliable and an uncounselled confession failed constitutional standards. A criminal conviction cannot stand on suspicion, shaky identification, or a confession taken without the safeguards required by the Constitution. For accused persons, victims, witnesses, and families involved in criminal cases, the ruling in People v. Janson is […]

Coerced Confessions Cannot Convict: Why Courts Must Exclude Evidence Obtained Through Force

A coerced confession cannot convict an accused. The Court excluded doubtful confessions, affirmed two convictions, and acquitted two others on reasonable doubt. A confession extracted through force, threat, intimidation, or custodial pressure cannot be used to send a person to prison. People v. Guillermo is a reminder that criminal convictions must rest on reliable, independent […]