Missed Electronic Filing Can End Customs Criminal Cases Before They Begin

A customs criminal case was terminated after prosecutors missed the 24-hour PDF filing rule; heavy workload did not justify reconsideration. Prosecutors, importers, brokers, and companies facing customs enforcement should treat the Court of Tax Appeals’ electronic filing rules as jurisdiction-critical litigation requirements: a paper-filed criminal information may be deemed not filed if the required PDF […]

Customs Smuggling Charges Fail When Prosecutors Cannot Prove Importation

The tax court acquitted an importer in a customs smuggling case after prosecutors failed to prove that the alleged cigarette shipment was actually imported. Importers and customs brokers facing criminal smuggling charges should closely examine whether the prosecution can prove the first and most basic fact: that the goods were actually imported into the Philippines. […]

Customs Criminal Cases Can Be Dismissed When Probable Cause Evidence Is Incomplete

Customs fraud information dismissed without prejudice after the prosecution failed to submit annexes needed to establish probable cause before the Court of Tax Appeals. Importers and business owners facing customs fraud charges should know that a criminal case cannot proceed on allegations alone: before an arrest warrant may issue, the Court of Tax Appeals must […]

Customs Criminal Cases Can Be Dismissed When Prosecutors Fail to Submit Complete Supporting Evidence

Customs misdeclaration charge dismissed without prejudice after prosecutors failed to submit complete supporting evidence for probable cause before the tax court. Importers, customs brokers, and company officers facing customs criminal charges should not assume that the filing of an Information automatically means an arrest warrant or trial will follow. Before a customs prosecution may proceed, […]

Arrastre Burden Rule: Cargo Loss Liability in Philippine Ports

Arrastre operators bear the burden to prove due care; a clean release receipt does not defeat cargo-loss claims when negligence and prior value notice are shown. The Arrastre Burden Rule means that a port cargo handler cannot avoid liability for missing cargo merely by pointing to a clean release receipt or suggesting that another party […]

When Customs Releases Garnished Cargo Without Authority, the Collector Can Be Liable

Customs officials may be liable when bonded warehouse goods are released without proper authority, even if a subordinate caused the misdelivery. Importers, consignees, judgment creditors, and cargo owners have a powerful remedy when goods in customs custody are released without proper authority: the Collector of Customs may be held officially liable for the loss, even […]