A Rape Conviction Can Stand on Credible Testimony, But Death Penalty Requires Strict Proof of Qualifying Facts

Credible victim testimony sustained three rape convictions, but the death penalty was reduced because minority and relationship were not properly alleged and proven. In rape prosecutions, a victim’s credible and consistent testimony may be enough to convict, even without extensive physical injuries or conclusive medical findings. But if the State seeks the death penalty or […]

Rape Convictions Cannot Rest on a Theory the Accused Was Never Required to Defend Against

Rape conviction reversed because the prosecution failed to prove the charged mode of force or intimidation and could not rely on an uncharged theory. A criminal conviction must stand or fall on the charge actually made, not on a different theory discovered only after trial. In People v. Mendigurin, the Supreme Court acquitted an accused […]

When a Defective Rape Information Reduces the Penalty but Not the Conviction

The Court upheld rape convictions but reduced the penalty where the information failed to allege minority and relationship as qualifying facts. A criminal conviction may stand even when the charging document is imperfect, but the penalty can be reduced if the information fails to allege the facts that make the offense qualified. For accused persons, […]

Death Penalty Cannot Stand When the Information Fails to Allege the Qualifying Circumstance

A rape conviction was affirmed, but the death penalty was barred because the qualifying father-daughter relationship was not alleged in the information. An accused may be convicted on the strength of a victim’s credible testimony, but a court cannot impose the death penalty unless the facts that legally qualify the offense for death are specifically […]

A Criminal Information Limits What the Court May Convict You Of

A rape charge alleging force did not support conviction for simple seduction because deceit was not alleged. Courts may convict only on the charge as written. A person charged with one crime cannot be convicted of another offense unless the lesser offense is necessarily included in the charge as written. In Barba, the Court applied […]