BIR Collection Cases Can Die on Prescription When the Government Cannot Prove Notice

The Supreme Court barred a BIR collection suit where the government filed beyond five years and failed to prove receipt of the later deficiency assessment. A taxpayer may defeat a BIR collection suit when the government files too late and cannot prove that a later deficiency assessment was actually received. In Republic of the Philippines […]

Backpay Certificates Cannot Be Used by Assignees to Pay Taxes

Assignees of backpay certificates cannot use them to pay their own taxes; invalid tender leaves the tax unpaid, with surcharge and interest due. Taxpayers who acquire backpay certificates from someone else cannot use those certificates to wipe out their own tax liabilities. The privilege to pay taxes with backpay certificates belongs only to the original […]

Tax Deduction Timing Rule: When Business Losses Become Deductible

Business losses are deductible only in the proper tax year when worthlessness, charge-off, business purpose, and legal basis are proven. The tax deduction timing rule matters because a business cannot choose the most convenient year to deduct a loss, bad debt, depreciation, or depletion claim. A taxpayer must prove that the loss became deductible in […]

When a Taxpayer Waits Too Long, the Tax Court Loses Power to Help

A taxpayer cannot revive an expired BIR assessment appeal by repeating reconsideration requests after final action. Late CTA petitions are jurisdictionally barred. A tax assessment cannot be kept alive for review by repeatedly asking the BIR to reconsider the same issue after the Commissioner has already made a final decision. Once the taxpayer receives a […]