Foreign Airlines Can Be Taxed on Philippine Ticket Sales Even Without Landing Here

Foreign airlines may owe Philippine tax on local ticket sales despite no Philippine flights, but good-faith legal error does not automatically prove tax fraud. Foreign airlines that sell tickets in the Philippines may owe Philippine income tax on those sales even if their planes never land in the country. The controlling doctrine is source-based taxation: […]

When Tax Assessments Are Based on Guesswork, Taxpayers Can Fight Back

A tax assessment based on estimates and presumptions cannot stand without factual proof. Taxpayers may challenge speculative BIR computations before the CTA. Taxpayers may defeat a tax assessment when the government relies on presumptions, estimates, or mathematical projections instead of actual facts. In Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Island Garment Manufacturing Corporation, the Court reaffirmed […]

Tax Deductions Fail When Bonuses Look Like Profit Distributions, Not Payment for Services

Officer profit-sharing bonuses were not deductible without proof of services, and late tax-exemption claims could not defeat a BIR deficiency assessment. Corporate taxpayers cannot convert profit-sharing payments to officers into deductible business expenses merely by calling them bonuses. When a claimed deduction is not tied to actual personal services, and when a tax-exemption theory is […]

Taxpayers Cannot Save a Failed Assessment Case by Raising Exemption Too Late

A taxpayer cannot raise a tax-exemption theory for the first time in court; officer bonuses tied to a land sale were disallowed, and surcharge plus interest were sustained. A taxpayer who accepts the tax character of a transaction during the administrative assessment stage cannot later ask the courts to treat the same income as tax-exempt […]

When Tax Penalties Start After a Court-Modified Assessment

Court-modified tax assessments trigger surcharge only after finality and nonpayment within 30 days, but taxpayers and heirs remain liable for penalties. Taxpayers who lose a tax case after the court modifies the BIR assessment do not automatically owe delinquency penalties from the original assessment date; the decisive date is when the judgment fixing the final […]

Good Faith Is Not a Shield Against Tax Deficiency Interest and Surcharges

Good faith reliance on prior tax guidance did not stop deficiency interest and surcharge once the income tax assessment remained unpaid. Good faith tax disputes do not stop statutory deficiency interest and surcharges from running. Once a taxpayer fails to pay an assessed income tax deficiency on time, the statutory additions may be collected even […]

When Tax Deductions Fail: The Supreme Court’s Proof-First Rule for Corporate Losses and Bad Debts

Corporate deductions require proof, timing, and statutory authority; Fernandez Hermanos limits bad debts, losses, depreciation, and depletion claims. Corporate taxpayers cannot deduct losses, bad debts, depreciation, or depletion merely because an amount appears in their books or because management believes an asset has lost value. Fernandez Hermanos teaches a stricter rule: tax deductions must be […]

Tax-Exempt Government Bonds Do Not Make the Land Sale Tax-Free

Government bond tax exemptions cover bond interest, not gains from land transfers paid in bonds. Property owners may still owe income tax on realized gain. Landowners paid with tax-exempt government bonds may still owe income tax on the gain from the transfer of their property. The tax exemption follows the bond interest, not the sale […]

When the Taxpayer Files No Return, the Government Has Ten Years to Sue

Failure to file an income tax return allows the Government to sue for collection within ten years from discovery, defeating a three-year prescription defense. A taxpayer who fails to file an income tax return cannot rely on the ordinary three-year assessment period to defeat collection. In tax cases involving omission of returns, the Government may […]