Lawyers May Use Strong Words in Demand Letters When They Are Relevant to the Client’s Case

The Supreme Court dismissed a disbarment complaint, holding that harsh language in a legal notice may be protected when relevant to a client’s case. Lawyers do not automatically face discipline for using harsh or unflattering words in a legal notice, demand letter, or advocacy document if the statement is relevant to the dispute, made in […]

Lawyers Can Be Suspended for Bouncing Checks, Even in Private Transactions

A lawyer may be suspended for issuing worthless checks, even in a private transaction, because the act constitutes serious misconduct under legal ethics rules. A lawyer who issues worthless checks may be disciplined as a lawyer even when the transaction is private, unrelated to court work, and still the subject of separate criminal proceedings. For […]

A Disbarment Complaint Cannot Substitute for Trial When the Real Fight Is Over Facts

Disbarment cannot replace trial when alleged lawyer dishonesty depends on unresolved civil or criminal facts, but lawyers may still be reprimanded for ignoring court orders. Clients who believe an opposing lawyer used false statements, questionable documents, or baseless pleadings cannot always win disbarment by proving that the underlying litigation is bitter or fact-heavy. When the […]

When a Disbarment Complaint Fails: Due Process Does Not Always Mean a Reply or Memorandum

Disbarment complainants have no automatic right to file a reply when the Supreme Court can resolve the case from the existing record. Parties who file disbarment complaints cannot assume that every attorney discipline case will proceed through reply, memorandum, or a formal notice that the matter is submitted for resolution. The Supreme Court reaffirmed that […]

Attorney-Client Privilege Is Not a Shield Against Public Records: When Confidentiality Claims Fail

The Court held that attorney-client privilege requires proof of a specific confidential legal communication, not merely a past lawyer-client relationship. A former client cannot defeat a lawyer’s complaint or disciplinary defense merely by invoking attorney-client privilege in general terms. To prove a violation, the complaining party must identify the specific confidential communication, show that it […]

Lawyer Discipline Requires a Real Hearing When the Facts Are Disputed

The Court remanded a lawyer misconduct case because disputed facts required a formal IBP investigation before suspension or notarial sanctions. Clients who accuse a lawyer of mishandling property, notarizing questionable documents, or refusing to release titles may trigger professional discipline, but disputed misconduct cannot be resolved by paperwork alone. Where the record shows contested facts […]

When a Notarization Complaint Becomes a Family Property Weapon

The Court dismissed a notary misconduct complaint, holding that alleged improper notarization must be conclusively proven, not inferred from a family property fight. A notary public cannot be disciplined on suspicion alone: even a troubling notarized deed, signed close to death and later attacked in a family property dispute, will not justify disbarment unless professional […]