Tax Evasion Charges Can Collapse When BIR Cannot Prove Receipt of Assessment Notices

A criminal tax case failed after the prosecution could not prove valid receipt of assessment notices or grave abuse in the taxpayer’s acquittal. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges for failure to pay assessed taxes may defeat the case if the prosecution cannot prove, with competent evidence, that the required assessment notices were actually received by […]

Government Tax Prosecutions Face a Jurisdiction Trap After Demurrer-Based Acquittals

The tax court dismissed the governmentโ€™s Rule 65 challenge for lack of jurisdiction after a demurrer-based acquittal in a criminal tax case. Taxpayers facing criminal tax cases before the Court of Tax Appeals gain a significant procedural advantage when the prosecution loses on demurrer to evidence: the government may still attempt a Rule 65 challenge, […]

Tax Criminal Acquittals Are Hard to Undo Without OSG Authority and True Grave Abuse

Tax court affirms acquittal in a criminal tax case, holding that the BIR lacked OSG authority and failed to show grave abuse to overcome double jeopardy. Tax prosecutors and revenue officers cannot treat a criminal tax acquittal as an ordinary adverse ruling that may simply be challenged by the BIR on its own. When the […]

Tax Demurrer Acquittal Rule: When BIR Tax Charges Fail

Criminal tax acquittals after demurrer are final unless grave abuse is shown, but civil tax liability may still proceed separately. The Tax Demurrer Acquittal Rule gives accused taxpayers and corporate officers powerful protection: once a criminal tax case is dismissed after the prosecutionโ€™s evidence fails, the acquittal is generally final, and the government cannot use […]

Tax Amnesty Is Not a Shortcut Out of Criminal Tax Cases When the Disclosure Was Not Voluntary

Tax amnesty protects only taxpayers who strictly qualify; it cannot stop criminal tax cases when disclosure was not voluntary or already under investigation. Taxpayers cannot use a tax amnesty as a shield against criminal prosecution when the supposed disclosure was not voluntary, when the government already had the information through an informer or investigation, or […]