A Lost Ejectment Case Cannot Be Revived Through Certiorari

Losing occupants cannot use certiorari to revive missed appeals in ejectment cases; final judgments may be executed despite ownership claims. Tenants, occupants, and property claimants who lose an ejectment case cannot later stop demolition by filing a separate certiorari action if they simply failed to use the ordinary remedies available to them. The ruling draws […]

When a Tenant Withdraws an Appeal, Execution Does Not Rewind Time

A withdrawn appeal makes a judgment final only upon effective withdrawal and remand; a lessee may receive indemnity for improvements but cannot force a land sale. A party who appeals a judgment and later withdraws that appeal cannot treat the case as if the appeal never existed. The judgment becomes final only when the withdrawal […]

Courts Cannot Demolish a Defendantโ€™s House Without a Hearing and Time to Remove It

Courts may enforce ejectment judgments, but demolition of improvements requires a special order, hearing, and reasonable time for removal. A person who loses an ejectment case may be ordered to vacate, but the winning party does not automatically get the right to have the losing partyโ€™s house or improvements demolished. Before demolition may proceed, the […]

Rent Control Can Stop Ejectment Even When the Lease Has Expired

Rent-control legislation may suspend ejectment based on lease expiration, and police power can override ordinary contract remedies in housing disputes. Landlords cannot use an expired lease term alone to eject residential occupants when rent-control legislation has suspended that very ground for ejectment. In Gutierrez v. Cantada, the controlling lesson is a police-power doctrine with direct […]

Minor Pleading Defects Do Not Prove Lawyer Misconduct Without Prejudice or Deceit

A procedural defect in an ejectment complaint did not justify discipline absent proof of deceit, prejudice, or bad faith by counsel. Not every procedural defect in a court filing becomes a disciplinary offense. A party who loses a case cannot convert ordinary pleading objections into a disbarment case unless the record shows actual deceit, bad […]

When a Land Dispute Is Really a Boundary Case, Consent Cannot Create Court Jurisdiction

Consent cannot give a court jurisdiction. A judge was exonerated for dismissing a forcible entry case that was actually a boundary dispute. Parties cannot cure a courtโ€™s lack of jurisdiction by agreeing on how their dispute should be decided. In land possession cases, especially those involving alleged encroachment, the decisive question is not merely what […]