Proven Tolerance Rule: Why Ejectment Failed in a Property Dispute

Unlawful detainer fails when tolerance is unproven and the one-year period has lapsed; property owners may need a full civil action. The Proven Tolerance Rule warns property owners that an ejectment case cannot rest on bare claims that an occupant was merely allowed to stay out of kindness. In Philippine property litigation, a party who […]

Torrens Title Possession Rule: Why Cities Must Vacate Private Land

A defective real property donation gives no possessory right; Torrens owners and heirs may recover land despite long government occupation and laches defenses. The Torrens Title Possession Rule protects registered landowners and their heirs even against long government occupation: a city cannot defeat a certificate of title by relying on a defective donation, tax declarations, […]

Bare Tolerance Rule: Why Ejectment Requires Proof of Permission

Unlawful detainer requires proof of actual tolerance; long possession and tax declarations can defeat summary ejectment in Philippine courts. The Bare Tolerance Rule protects occupants from being summarily ejected on nothing more than a landholder’s unsupported claim that they were merely allowed to stay. In Philippine unlawful detainer cases, a property claimant must prove not […]