Equitable Mortgage Rule: When a Sale Is Really a Loan Security

A pacto de retro sale may be treated as an equitable mortgage when possession, taxes, and conduct show it secured a loan. Property owners who sign a deed of sale with right to repurchase may still prove that the transaction was only an equitable mortgage if the surrounding facts show that the document was meant […]

Equitable Mortgage Doctrine: SC Upholds Contractual Intent in Property Repurchase

SC confirms that clear repurchase options in property sales create enforceable rights under Philippine law, emphasizing intent over formalities in equitable mortgages. Property owners and investors must now recognize that a clear contractual option to repurchase, even when paired with an absolute sale, is enforceable if the parties’ intent is explicit. The Supreme Court clarified […]

Equitable Mortgage Presumption: When a Deed of Sale Secures a Loan

The Supreme Court confirmed that a deed of sale may function as an equitable mortgage if intended to secure a loan, emphasizing party intent over document form and remanding for loan settlement determination. Property owners and creditors now have clearer guidance on when a deed of sale may be treated as an equitable mortgage, emphasizing […]

Tax Declarations Can Help Prove Who Really Owns and Possesses Property

Tax declarations and tax payments helped prove that a supposed deed of sale was really an equitable mortgage, preserving ownership subject to loan payment. Tax declarations do not by themselves create ownership, but they can become powerful evidence when a property dispute turns on who actually possessed, paid for, and treated the land as owner. […]

Tax Declarations Cannot Turn a Mortgage Into a Sale

A deed called a sale with right to repurchase may be treated as an equitable mortgage when possession, tax payments, and conduct show a loan. Property owners who sign a deed that looks like a sale may still prove that the transaction was only a loan secured by land. The Matanguihan ruling is important for […]

Tax-Motivated Property Transfers Cannot Turn a Loan Into a Sale

A deed of sale used to secure a loan may be treated as an equitable mortgage, even when title transfers appear tax-driven and formally documented. Property owners who sign deeds of sale to secure a debt may still recover the protection of an equitable mortgage when the surrounding facts show that the transaction was really […]

When a Deed of Sale Is Really a Mortgage: Why Courts Look Beyond the Paper Title

A deed labeled as a sale may be treated as an equitable mortgage when facts show it secured a loan, affecting title, buyer rights, and tax analysis. A property owner who signs a document called a deed of sale is not always treated as having permanently sold the property. When the surrounding facts show that […]