Proven Tolerance Rule: Why Ejectment Failed in a Property Dispute

Unlawful detainer fails when tolerance is unproven and the one-year period has lapsed; property owners may need a full civil action. The Proven Tolerance Rule warns property owners that an ejectment case cannot rest on bare claims that an occupant was merely allowed to stay out of kindness. In Philippine property litigation, a party who […]

Forged Deed Rule: When a Land Sale Transfers No Title

A forged deed transfers no land title in the Philippines, and defective notarization may let heirs cancel a title issued from the fake sale. The forged deed rule protects heirs and property owners from losing land through a paper sale that carries the appearance of formality but lacks genuine consent. A notarized deed is powerful […]

When Tax Returns Enter a Family Property Fight, Timing Can Decide the Objection

Tax returns attached to pleadings are not yet evidence. Objections based on confidentiality must be raised when the documents are formally offered at trial. Income tax returns may be highly sensitive, but a party cannot defeat their use in litigation by objecting before they are formally offered as evidence. In Ty v. Court of Appeals, […]