Forgery in Mortgage Documents: SC Rules on Bank Liability and Property Rights

The SC held that forged mortgage documents are void ab initio and banks failing due diligence are liable; property owners may reclaim title and seek damages. When a bank fails to verify the authority of a mortgagor, the resulting mortgage is not protected, and property owners may reclaim their title even after foreclosure attempts. The […]

Tax Returns Can Make or Break Lost Income Claims After an Accident

Lost income after an accident must be proven with competent records. Tax returns, employer certifications, and withholding proof can decide actual damages claims. People claiming lost income in court cannot rely on memory, estimates, or sympathy alone. When an accident victim asks for compensation for missed earnings or impaired earning capacity, the claim must be […]

Courts Can Cut Unsupported Damage Awards Even When an Appeal Was Almost Lost on Technicalities

Property buyers may recover proven losses, but speculative construction costs cannot support compensatory damages in Philippine real estate fraud cases. Property buyers who are deceived in a land sale may recover what they actually paid and may receive moral or exemplary damages in proper cases, but courts will not award speculative construction losses simply because […]

When Store Security Goes Too Far: False Shoplifting Accusations Can Create Civil Liability

A supermarket may investigate suspected shoplifting, but public humiliation and false accusation can trigger moral damages when the facts show innocent mistake. Retailers may protect their goods, but they cannot turn loss prevention into public humiliation. A customer wrongly accused of shoplifting may recover damages when store personnel detain, interrogate, shame, or penalize him without […]

A Missing Court Stenographer Does Not Automatically Undo a Criminal Conviction

The Court held that a missing official stenographer did not void the conviction and affirmed damages for public defamation and slight physical injuries. A person convicted in a lower court cannot automatically restart the case simply because the original trial was not recorded by an official court stenographer. When an appeal reaches the proper court, […]