Tax Declarations Can Cut Both Ways in Expropriation: Why Government Valuations May Defeat Inflated Compensation Claims

The Supreme Court held that unsupported commissioners’ valuations may be rejected in expropriation when official appraisal records better prove market value. Property owners facing expropriation cannot rely on unsupported private valuations or generalized claims of market value when official assessment records show a lower, location-specific benchmark. In Bank of the Philippine Islands v. National Power […]

Just Compensation Is Valued Before Expropriation Distorts the Market

Just compensation in expropriation must be based on credible pre-taking land value, not inflated post-filing prices or unsupported commissioners’ reports. Landowners in expropriation cases cannot rely on inflated post-taking prices or unsupported appraisal reports to increase compensation. When the government takes private land for a public project, the controlling valuation is the fair market value […]

When Government Takes Land First, Compensation Is Based on Value at the Time of Taking

Just compensation in expropriation is based on the land’s value at the time of taking, not later subdivision plans or future development potential. Property owners whose land is taken by the government cannot increase compensation by pointing to later development plans, subdivision potential, or rising market values after the taking. Just compensation is measured by […]