Heirs Cannot Use a Corporate Case to Divide Inherited Shares Before Estate Settlement

Heirs disputing inherited corporate shares must pursue estate settlement, not a commercial or derivative suit, when the real issue is succession and partition. Heirs claiming ownership of shares in a family corporation cannot shortcut probate by filing a corporate case for accounting, derivative relief, or alleged corporate fraud. When the real dispute is who among […]

When Corporate Stock Records Are Incomplete, Shareholders May Still Prove Ownership and Voting Rights

Shareholders may prove voting rights through articles and other records when the stock and transfer book is incomplete, affecting quorum and control. Shareholders are not automatically stripped of voting rights simply because their names, or their predecessors’ names, do not appear in the corporation’s stock and transfer book. Where the corporation’s articles of incorporation, conduct, […]

When a Corporation Cannot Sue Because Its Own Board Authority Is Defective

Corporate lawsuits can fail when the representative cannot prove valid board authority. The ruling shows why SEC filings and board records matter in disputes. A corporation may own property, enforce contracts, and recover assets in court, but it can do so only through officers or agents who are validly authorized by its board of directors. […]

Family Corporations, Land Transfers, and the Limits of Piercing the Corporate Veil

Family corporations remain separate from shareholders absent proof of fraud; late documentary stamp tax objections will not automatically void share transfers. Family-owned corporations cannot be disregarded merely because relatives used them to hold land, transfer shares, or structure estate-related arrangements. A party asking a court to treat corporate property as personally owned must prove that […]

Minority Shareholders Can Sue Directly to Stop Dilution of Their Preemptive Rights

Minority shareholders may sue directly to stop stock issuances that dilute preemptive rights; the action is not necessarily derivative. Minority shareholders do not always need to sue in the name of the corporation when the injury is personal to them. When a stock issuance threatens to dilute a shareholder’s ownership and preemptive rights, the shareholder […]

Family Business Profits Are Not Partnership Shares Without Proof of Intent

Family business involvement does not prove partnership. The Court required clear evidence of contribution, common fund, and intent to share profits. Heirs cannot claim a share in a family business as partnership property merely because a deceased relative helped build the enterprise, managed operations, lived near the business, or received payments connected with its success. […]

Cancelled Stock Certificates Cannot Defeat a Valid Corporate Dissolution Vote

Shareholders with real two-thirds stock ownership may approve dissolution; void or simulated stock transfers cannot defeat their voting rights. Corporate shareholders who validly hold at least two-thirds of a corporation’s outstanding capital stock may approve voluntary dissolution, and management cannot defeat that vote by relying on simulated, undocumented, or void stock transfers that were later […]

When Director Pay Is Not Automatically Illegal: The Corporate Compensation Rule Every School and Family Corporation Should Know

Directors may be paid for real officer services, not merely board seats. The ruling also limits civil recovery after acquittal and forum shopping in corporate disputes. Directors and trustees are not automatically barred from receiving compensation from their own corporation when they are being paid for actual officer work, management duties, or services separate from […]

Stock Certificates Are Evidence, Not Ownership: Why Share Transfers Can Still Bind Corporate Insiders

Share transfers may bind corporate insiders despite certificate issues when records, conduct, and equity show the transaction was completed and recognized. Corporate insiders cannot defeat a completed stock transfer simply by keeping or refusing to endorse a certificate after the corporation has already recognized the transfer in its books. For shareholders, directors, and family-owned corporations, […]

Stockholders Do Not Own Corporate Property: Why Share Transfers Cannot Let Heirs Control Company Assets

Stockholders do not own corporate property directly, and unrecorded share transfers cannot support intervention in litigation over corporate assets. Stockholders who inherit or receive shares do not automatically acquire ownership over the corporation’s land, buildings, or other assets. Their remedy is generally against the shares or the corporation through proper proceedings, not direct intervention in […]