POGO Challenges Require Real Injury, Not Just Taxpayer Objections

Taxpayers cannot challenge PAGCOR’s POGO rules without direct injury, illegal fund disbursement, and proper observance of judicial review rules. Taxpayers and concerned citizens cannot stop a government revenue or regulatory program merely by alleging that it is unconstitutional. They must show a real, direct, and personal injury, or a clearly illegal expenditure of public funds; […]

Express Gambling Franchise Rule: Why PAGCOR Could Not Run Jai-Alai

PAGCOR needed clear legislative authority to operate jai-alai; broad charter language could not imply a gambling franchise. Government gaming authority is not a blank check: under the Express Gambling Franchise Rule, even PAGCOR must point to a clear legislative franchise before operating or authorizing a specific gambling activity such as jai-alai. For businesses dealing with […]

Franchise Non-Delegation: PAGCOR Cannot Expand Jai-Alai Powers

PAGCOR cannot imply a jai-alai franchise from its casino charter; government franchises need clear legislative authority. Government franchises cannot be enlarged by implication when the activity is politically sensitive, commercially valuable, and reserved to legislative control. The Franchise Non-Delegation Doctrine matters because a corporation dealing with a government agency cannot rely on a broad or […]

PAGCOR Tax Supremacy: Why Local Fees Cannot Block Gaming Operations

Local governments cannot impose fees that obstruct PAGCOR’s national charter; constitutional attacks require a clear breach of the Constitution. The PAGCOR tax supremacy doctrine confirms that local governments cannot use license fees or local taxes to block a national government instrumentality from carrying out a gambling franchise authorized by Congress. For businesses operating in heavily […]

PAGCOR’s Tax Exemption Survives: Why Local Governments Cannot Tax National Gaming Operations

PAGCOR’s charter tax exemption bars local governments from imposing taxes or fees that would frustrate Congress’s national policy on gaming regulation. Local governments cannot impose taxes, fees, or regulatory charges on PAGCOR’s gaming operations when Congress has placed those operations under a national charter and expressly exempted them from local taxation. For businesses and public […]