Paid Government Contract Awards Can Be Executed Without a Detour to COA

Final arbitral awards against government agencies may be executed when the State acted commercially and COA cannot reopen the judgment. Private parties who have fully paid for property under a confirmed arbitral award are not required to restart the dispute before the Commission on Audit simply because the other party is the government. When the […]

When a Failed Government-Backed Loan Is Not Enough for a Graft Case

Failed government-backed loans do not automatically prove graft; the Ombudsmanโ€™s no-probable-cause finding stands absent grave abuse of discretion. A government loss, a failed development project, or even a loan later suspected to be politically favored does not automatically create a graft case. The decisive question is whether investigators can show probable cause that public officers […]

When an Irregular Government Loan Is Not Automatically Graft

Irregular LGU loan transactions are not automatically graft; prosecutors must prove gross and manifest disadvantage beyond reasonable doubt. Public officers are not guilty of graft merely because a government loan transaction was irregular, poorly documented, or later criticized as financially risky. To convict under the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act for entering into a contract […]

FTAA Contract Jurisdiction Rule: Why Forum Matters in Mining Disputes

FTAA cancellations are contractual administrative acts, not Rule 43 judgments; parties must use the proper court remedy to challenge mining contract validity. Government resource contracts cannot be attacked, appealed, or defended as if every executive action were a court judgment. The FTAA Contract Jurisdiction Rule teaches a practical lesson for companies dealing with mining rights, […]

Procurement Funding Rule: Why Budget Must Come Before Bidding

Government projects need lawful funding before procurement starts; later appropriations may cure mootness but cannot erase irregular public bidding defects. Government procurement cannot be treated as a promise to find money later. Under the Procurement Funding Rule, agencies must have sufficient appropriation, and where required a Multi-Year Obligational Authority, before starting procurement for public projects. […]

A Criminal Case Cannot Be Thrown Out Before the Prosecution Presents Its Evidence

The Court held that weak evidence cannot justify dismissal before trial; a motion to quash tests the charge, not the prosecutionโ€™s proof. Criminal defendants may challenge a defective charge early, but they cannot convert a motion to quash into a premature trial on the evidence. In People v. Dumlao, the Court drew a firm line […]