A Desistance Affidavit Cannot End a Public Crime Without Prosecutorial Scrutiny

Affidavit of desistance cannot alone dismiss a public crime; the judge was fined for mishandling preliminary investigation records. Victims and heirs cannot privately erase a criminal case simply by signing an affidavit of desistance, especially when the offense charged is a public crime. In Padua v. Judge Molina, the Supreme Court made clear that judges […]

When a Complaint Against a Judge Is Withdrawn After Settlement, Administrative Discipline May End Too

The Supreme Court dismissed a judicial misconduct complaint after withdrawal, factual clarification, and settlement of the related agrarian cases. Administrative complaints against judges can be dismissed when the complainants themselves withdraw the charges, admit that the complaint arose from misunderstanding or inaccurate reports, and show that the underlying cases have already been settled. For litigants, […]

A Guilty Plea Cannot Shortcut a Criminal Case Without Prosecutor Notice and Consent

A judge cannot accept a guilty plea to a lesser offense without proper prosecutor notice and factual basis; the defective conviction may be reopened. A trial judge cannot quietly reduce a serious criminal prosecution by accepting a guilty plea to a lesser offense when the prosecutors are not properly notified, the evidence does not clearly […]

When a Judge Is Not Disciplined for Dismissing a Weak Labor Caseโ€”But Is Warned to Investigate More Carefully

A judge was not disciplined for dismissing labor-related criminal cases, but was warned to investigate employee-status evidence more carefully. A judge who dismisses a labor-related criminal complaint for insufficient evidence will not automatically face discipline merely because a labor official disagrees with the ruling. But the decision also carries a caution: where employee status, statutory […]

Losing in Court Is Not Enough to Discipline a Judge

Judicial discipline requires proof of bad faith or bias, not mere disagreement with a ruling. The judge was exonerated after the charges lacked evidence. A judge is not administratively liable merely because a party believes the ruling was wrong. To discipline a judge for alleged grave abuse of discretion or partiality, the complainant must show […]