Candidate Withdrawal After Supreme Court Relief Can Still Lead to Contempt

The Supreme Court dismissed a moot election petition but fined the candidate for indirect contempt after he withdrew shortly after obtaining TRO relief. A litigant who urgently asks the Supreme Court to stop government action cannot treat the Courtโ€™s relief as a temporary tactical device and then abandon the controversy in a way that wastes […]

Clear Tax Exemption Rule: Why Franchise Assets Still Face Realty Tax

Tax exemptions must be clear; franchise real properties remain taxable unless the law plainly exempts them from local real property tax. Tax exemptions must be written in clear and unmistakable language; a franchise holder cannot stop a real property tax levy simply by relying on an implied exemption or an earlier judgment against different local […]

When Court Criticism Becomes Contempt: The Line Between Legitimate Advocacy and Scurrilous Attacks

The Court fined a complainant for indirect contempt after unfounded attacks on justices, clarifying when strong criticism of court delay becomes punishable. Litigants may criticize judges and court decisions, but they cross into contempt when their language stops being a good-faith challenge to legal error and becomes a scurrilous attack on the integrity of the […]

Judges Cannot Jail Parties for Indirect Contempt Without Due Process

Indirect contempt requires a written charge and hearing before arrest. The Court fined a retired judge and voided an improper arrest order. Indirect contempt cannot be punished by arrest first and hearing later. When a judge orders a person jailed for allegedly disobeying a writ, the court must first require a written charge and give […]

When a Contempt Order Follows Missed Court Dates: What Accused Persons and Litigants Must Know

Court orders must be challenged through proper remedies. Administrative complaints cannot replace an appeal from an indirect contempt ruling. Litigants who are cited in indirect contempt must challenge the contempt finding through the proper remedy, not through an administrative complaint against the judge, especially when the record shows that they were given notice, heard, and […]

When Courtroom Criticism Becomes Contempt: Why Judges Cannot Jail Litigants Without the Right Process

Court criticism filed before another office is indirect contempt, not direct contempt, and may be privileged against libel when made in good faith. A litigant who attacks a judge in a complaint filed before another government office may face consequences, but not through summary punishment as direct contempt. The governing principle is procedural: disrespectful language […]