When a Corporate By-Law Is Fixed, the Court May Refuse to Decide the Fight

A corrected corporate by-law can moot a governance case, leaving courts unable to issue advisory rulings on SEC powers or board election disputes. A corporate governance case can disappear before judgment when the corporation corrects the challenged by-law and no practical relief remains for the parties. For companies, stockholders, and directors, the ruling teaches a […]

When a Status Quo Order Goes Too Far: Why Courts Cannot Use It to Undo Corporate Acts Without Bond and Verification

A status quo order cannot reinstate a removed corporate officer without proper injunctive safeguards, including verification, hearing, and bond. A status quo order in an intra-corporate dispute cannot be used as a shortcut to reinstate a removed officer, trustee, or administrator. If the order effectively commands the undoing of an already completed corporate act, it […]

Proxy Fights Over Corporate Director Elections Belong in Court, Not the SEC

Proxy disputes tied to director elections belong in regular courts, not the SEC, even when framed as proxy-solicitation violations. Stockholders challenging proxies used to elect corporate directors must bring the dispute before the regular courts, not the Securities and Exchange Commission. Even when the objection is framed as a violation of SEC proxy-solicitation rules, the […]

Injunctions Cannot Save an Expired Corporate Office: Why Clear Legal Rights Matter in Boardroom Disputes

A removed university president failed to prove a clear right to office, so injunction was improper; by-laws and due process records controlled. A corporate officer who cannot prove a present, unmistakable legal right to remain in office cannot use an injunction to hold on to the position. For presidents, trustees, directors, school administrators, and nonprofit […]

Church Corporations Can Change Their Structure Without Dissolving First

Religious corporations may convert from corporation sole to aggregate by amended articles, preserving continuity without dissolution when approvals are met. A religious corporation organized as a corporation sole does not necessarily have to die before it can become a corporation aggregate. When the required corporate approvals are obtained and the amendment serves a legitimate purpose, […]

When Suspicion Is Not Enough: How Corporations Must Prove Fraud in Share Transfers

Suspicion alone cannot void a share transfer. Fraud must be proven clearly, and stock ownership may exist before the certificate is issued. A corporation that suspects insider dealing in the sale and resale of its shares cannot recover damages or undo the transaction on suspicion alone. Fraud must be pleaded and proven by clear and […]

When Corporate Factions Sue Too Many Times: The Supreme Courtโ€™s Warning Against Forum Shopping

The Supreme Court clarified forum shopping limits, management committee relief, and voting rules in non-stock corporate leadership disputes. Corporate and association disputes cannot be fought through repeated, overlapping cases in different tribunals just to secure a more favorable ruling. When rival factions recycle the same allegations, parties, and reliefs across multiple proceedings, courts may treat […]

Non-Voting Shares Are Not Automatic: Why Stock Classifications Cannot Strip Ordinary Shareholders of Control

Ordinary shares cannot be stripped of voting rights unless validly classified as preferred or redeemable; the Court protected Class B shareholdersโ€™ control rights. Corporations cannot make ordinary shares practically powerless simply by labeling them as a separate class. Unless a share is validly classified and issued as preferred or redeemable, the shareholder generally keeps the […]